Home / Opinions / Xbox One S vs Xbox One: Worth the upgrade?

Xbox One S vs Xbox One: Worth an upgrade?

Andy Vandervell

by

Xbox One S vs Xbox One: Is it worth buying either console with Project Scorpio specs now unveiled? TrustedReviews has put together everything you need to know.

Xbox One S isn't a significant upgrade over the Xbox One, but does provide some cool benefits. Owners now have access to HDR support and a 4K blu-ray player, something PS4 Pro sorely left out.

Buy the Xbox One S now from Amazon UK | Amazon.com

To put things simply, if you already own the original console there isn't much incentive to upgrade. Sure, there's the addition of HDR and 4K blu-ray support, but you'll need an impressive 4KTV to make any use of these features.

If you don't already own one, though, it's definitely worth considering a purchase. However, with Xbox Project Scorpio only a few months from launch, it makes things a little more complicated. TrustedReviews has broken down everything you need to know about the two consoles below, for anybody considering picking it up.

Related: Xbox Scorpio vs PS4 Pro

Xbox One S FAQ

Xbox One S release date? Out now.

Does it support 4K? Yes, for video and Blu-ray, games upscaled.

Is it more powerful? Yes, but only a little bit. There's a slight boost to processing power over the Xbox One to accommodate HDR gaming, but the difference is marginal.

Xbox One S Price: How much should you pay?

There are three different capacities. Prices started at £239 for the 500GB version, moving up to £299.95 for the 1TB and £399 for a massive 2TB. Prices have tumbled since launch, however, so you can get better deals that include bundled games.

Related: Nintendo Switch Review

Xbox One S is 40% smaller with built-in power supply

The Xbox One S is 40% smaller than the original – a considerable reduction. Given that the original Xbox One is a chunky machine – at 333mm x 276mm x 78mm, it dominates the comparatively slight PS4 – this is an important change. However, PS4 Slim gives Xbox One S a run for its money in terms of sheer dimensions. Plus the power supply is now built-in.

So, 40% smaller and no bulky power supply? That's a pretty big tick in favour of the Xbox One S.

Related: PS4 Pro vs PS4

4K Ultra HD, 4K Blu-ray and High Dynamic Range support

Arguably the standout feature for Xbox One S. Not only does the Xbox One S support 4K video playback from streaming services like Netflix and Amazon, it's also a 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray player. This makes the $299/£249 starting price excellent value compared to dedicated Ultra HD players currently available.

Our testing suggests the Xbox One S is a more than competent Ultra HD Blu-ray player, so AV fans should hold no fears in that regard.

Related: Best Xbox One Games

While the original Xbox One is technically capable of supporting 4K gaming and video, it has an HDMI 1.4a port, meaning it can only output 4K at 30Hz, which is very limiting. The Xbox One adds support for HDMI 2.0a, so it now supports proper 4K 60Hz output.

Xbox One S has a slight performance bump

Much like PS4 Pro, the Xbox One S is not the beginning of a new console generation, but an expansion of a platform we already know and love. But it does offer a very slight improvement over its predecessor.

The Coalition head Rod Fergusson revealed to Polygon that his team had taken advantage of additional raw GPU and CPU power for Gears of War 4 , to improve frame rates. Ferguson claimed his engineers have been able to, as Polygon puts it, “leverage the additional power to reduce the frequency of the frame rate or resolution penalties.”

Related: PS4 vs Xbox One

Xbox One S

A Microsoft spokesperson then confirmed, via The Verge, "We have the same SoC architecture as Xbox One today.

"For games that want to take advantage of HDR, we gave developers access to a small amount of additional processing power."

Overall though, don't expect games to look noticeably different on Xbox One S to Xbox One thanks to the additional power, instead only getting minor stability improvements.

Xbox One S can upscale games to 4K

The upscaling capabilities of the Xbox One S were revealed by Jeff Henshaw, Group Program Manager at Xbox at an E3 session.

Related: E3 2017

Xbox One 13

Henshaw said: "It's not native 4K, but the Xbox One S can upscale games from 1080p to 4K."

It means the Xbox One S will be able to offer gaming at a higher resolution than its predecessor, although it won't quite be as good as native 4K.

In our review, we found the Xbox One S is good at upscaling games and 4K video content – better than the TV we tested on.

It can be stored upright

That's great news, though the stand is an optional extra, unless you buy the 2TB model, which includes a stand.

There's no dedicated Kinect port

Not a huge surprise, given its increasing irrelevance, though owners who want to use Kinect can do say via a USB adapter. The adapter is sold seperately and can be ordered directly from Microsoft. Don't expect any new Kinect games on the horizon, though.

Related: Best Xbox One deals

Xbox One 15

But there is an IR blaster

In the place of a dedicated Kinect port, the Xbox One S comes with an integrated IR (infrared) blaster. That means you can configure your Xbox One S to turn on other devices, like your TV, audio/video receiver, and cable or satellite receiver.

The idea is that you can reduce the number of remotes you need to control your stuff.

Related: Upcoming Xbox One Games

Xbox One S IR

New controller adds Bluetooth

Not content with the already excellent Xbox One controller, or the incredible Xbox One Elite Controller, Microsoft's unveiled the Xbox One S controller as well.

Related: Xbox Game Pass

The pad has a new textured grip, exchangeable colour covers, extended range and – most importantly – now has Bluetooth so you can use it with a PC wirelessly.

Xbox One S vs Xbox One: Should you upgrade?

There's no doubt the new Xbox One S is a better all around console than its predecessor. Not only does it slim down the original console's bulky frame, the Xbox One S comes with a load of features that make a far more desirable device.

Firstly, you get a 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray player. Currently, those things will cost you upwards of £400 on their own. Secondly, you can stream 4K at the proper 60 Hz in HDR from apps such as Netflix and Amazon Prime Instant Video. Plus, there's even a slight performance boost. The console benefits from extra processing power, too.

It probably isn't worth it for most Xbox One owners if you don't care about 4K video, but it looks like a good upgrade if you fancy getting into Ultra HD Blu-ray. And if you don't already own an Xbox One, the smaller size and great features make it very tempting indeed.

But what about Scorpio?

While at the tail end of 2016 the choice between the two consoles seemed like a no-brainer, as we move closer the the supposed "holiday 2017" launch date of the Xbox Scorpio, the proposition becomes even trickier. There's still so much we don't know about Microsoft's all-powerful machine – most importantly, how much it will cost – but the fact this unit will represent a significant upgrade over anything that has come before it means that the idea of buying an Xbox One as a first-time buyer now becomes a bit of a tough sell.

Buy the Xbox One S now from Amazon UK | Amazon.com

With Digital Foundry having recently revealed the specifications for Project Scorpio, it's now easier decide whether you're willing to wait for the next big thing.

Will you be buying or upgrading to an Xbox One S? Let us know in the comments.

Caleb

June 13, 2016, 6:15 pm

I'm glad this article points out that the new Xbox won't be capable of 4k gaming. I'm tired of people being misinformed and thinking the PS4.5 and the Xbox One S will run games at 4k. Resolution isn't just a flip of a switch. You'd need at LEAST $1000 worth of hardware to even pretend to run 4k @ 30fps in LOW settings. No console in this generation or the next will manage that. However, 4k media streaming is totally plausible and worth being excited about.

dsr07mm

June 13, 2016, 6:28 pm

They actually announced officially that it's going to be support for true 4k resolution. Although I hope that I don't need to upgrade my PS4 because of PS4 Neo.

rahlquist

June 13, 2016, 6:41 pm

True 4k for streaming and perhaps games will output upsampled 1080p to 4k but thats not the same as true 4k gaming.

Caleb

June 13, 2016, 6:47 pm

I don't mean to be an elitist dick or anything, but as someone with extensive knowledge in computer hardware, I'm promising you that at a $300 pricepoint, it isn't going to be native 4k in-game resolution. The main thing holding back 4k media (blu-rays, streaming, etc.) is data transfer; being able to pull data off of a disc or off of a server fast enough to stream it (hence the upgraded Blu-ray drive and hdmi output), but as far as games are concerned, the biggest hurdle is graphical processing power. Even the new AMD GPU coming out soon, the RX 480, one of the best price/performance cards advertised right now, will barely handle 4k, and by barely, I mean low-medium settings @ 30fps. And that card will retail at $200 (supposedly). And honestly, I'm betting that some of the numbers from AMD are a little inflated at this point just to get the hype train going. But $200? That's literally 2/3rds of the Xbox One S price. Before even taking into account RAM, Processor, motherboard, the new internal power supply, the new and upgraded optical drive, etc. I'm not trying to be a pessimistic asshole, I just want people to know the truth about the hype. 4k media streaming? Totally plausible and reasonable. But native 4k gaming? Well.. the new Xbox would have to be AT LEAST $600-700 (assuming they used this new graphics card, if not, it would have to be more), and even then it would be a terrible experience that wouldn't last for very long. The hardware would be surpassed by games within a year or two and you'd need a new system just to run new games at low settings @ 4k again. Keep in mind, I'm only referring to AAA games with ultra gorgeous graphics. Low-end games would be easy to play at 4k, and honestly I think that might be how they can legally say "true 4k gaming". They probably can play low-end games at 4k and they use that as an excuse to exaggerate and say that the system is "powerful enough for true 4k gaming." It's classic advertisement misdirection.

greyskullg

June 13, 2016, 6:52 pm

Xbox One Scorpio will support 4K gaming. Confirmed by Spencer himself.

Muhammad Jihad ✓ᵛᵉʳᶦᶠᶦᵉᵈ

June 13, 2016, 7:16 pm

What moron wrote this article, why exactly is 4K 30hz useless for video. I suggest you the learn the basics kiddo.

Caleb

June 13, 2016, 7:30 pm

"Will support"... do you know what that could entail? I'm sure any Xbox could support Angry Birds at 4k, but it won't handle something new like The Division. Not unless the price is at least $500 and the graphics settings are set to ugly.

greyskullg

June 13, 2016, 8:05 pm

nah they said xbox scorpio is comparable to a high end gaming pc and will have graphics at a geforce 1070 rating

Caleb

June 13, 2016, 8:13 pm

So it's gonna cost over $1000.. just build a gaming PC?

greyskullg

June 13, 2016, 8:16 pm

they confirmed it will also have a console price, so it will be 500-600$ there doing this to destroy "budget gaming" this way you can spend half a g and have high end gaming

Caleb

June 13, 2016, 8:17 pm

Yeahhh... good luck with that.

Lamm

June 13, 2016, 11:21 pm

It's a hardware upgrade for the xboxOne, go to youtube and see for yourself.

dsr07mm

June 14, 2016, 3:06 am

It doesnt matter anymore. All games will be available on Windows so..pointless :)

dsr07mm

June 14, 2016, 3:06 am

"Support" is one thing. Windows is getting all Xbox games anyways so PC + PS4 is combo for further years.

dsr07mm

June 14, 2016, 3:07 am

It's not same architecture. That doesn't work like that. Wait and you will see.

daizyujin

June 14, 2016, 3:28 am

I am betting at the price point they are going for with a bulk rate and the fact they use AMD that it will be closer to an RX480.

andyvan

June 14, 2016, 10:00 am

Perhaps 'useless' is a tad strong, but plenty of video content is above 30fps these days, especially outside movies. Undesirable is probably a better word.

David Markham

June 14, 2016, 10:12 am

Well they did announce the Scorpion project - so next generation WILL have 4K gaming at 60fps. At what price point though...

Reclaimer13

June 14, 2016, 12:57 pm

The xbox one S can upscale games to 4k.. and supposedly it is more powerful than the standard xbox one.

Ryan Maye

June 14, 2016, 4:43 pm

Waste of money

Hvd

June 14, 2016, 6:09 pm

i herd it can up scale to 4k.the xbox one is the entry level consoles,the xbox one s is a mid level console that can upscale to 4k and the xbox scorpio is the high end native 4k console.

i have herd and reports are coming out that the xbox one s is upgraded and it has to be with hdr gaming.i cant wait for the specs for the xbox one s to be released.

Hvd

June 14, 2016, 6:11 pm

thats what i herd its lie entry level xbox one mid lvl 4k upscaled xbox one s and high end xbox scorpio because xbox one s has hdr gaming that means its upgraded maybe not as powerful as the ps4 neo but on par with the ps4 and it can be upscaled to 4k.

if you want to 4k game next year and cant get the xbox scorpio get the xbox one s and upscale it.

Mmillen

June 14, 2016, 6:27 pm

No, they said 980. not 1070

DJV1985

June 14, 2016, 9:23 pm

I will bitch and complain that they've brought out another version of the xbox after I bought it when it first came out for almost 400 quid but I'm probably going to get the newer console when it comes out as well (the 2tb console).

Muhammad Jihad ✓ᵛᵉʳᶦᶠᶦᵉᵈ

June 15, 2016, 3:52 am

Movies run at 24hz and TV runs at 30hz, unless you like the soap opera effect. Sports would be affected, but I have yet to see live 4K broadcasts of anything, it's certainly not an option on my cable provider. They should offer 4k @ 30hz, after all it's something they made of point of saying at launch, that the XB1 came with a 4K ready hdmi cable. I'm not sure how they could upgrade the HDMI connection to 2.0 via software, but if they can and they're not, then that's really just punishing early adopters for no reason at all. There is plenty of hardware there to run 4K video even if they think the dashboard would be too jerky, and the video being 4K is what 99% of people would care about anyways.

comments powered by Disqus