Breadmakers: Key tips and solutions to common baking problems

Although a bread maker nominally does it all for you, it’s not quite as simple as that. Getting the right mixture of ingredients, the right type of ingredients, and knowing how to store and add everything at the right time makes a huge difference to the quality of your final bread.

Whether you have recently acquired a bread maker or are looking to achieve better results with your machine, there are some basics to keep in mind when baking. First and foremost, it’s essential to get the right ingredients if you’re to achieve bread baking success.

Related: Best bread maker

Flour

When baking bread, use strong bread flour. It contains more gluten than plain flour, which helps the bread to rise. Plain flour can be used in breadmakers with a cake program – but this usually involves pre-mixing your ingredients and using the breadmaker simply as an oven.

Breadmaker tips

Yeast

Another vital ingredient for a beautiful loaf is yeast, which through the fermentation process produces the carbon dioxide necessary to make bread rise. Dried yeast that doesn’t require pre-fermentation is most suitable. It’s usually indicated on the packaging whether the yeast is breadmaker compatible. “Easy bake”, “fast action” and “quick” are words to look out for such yeast.

Dried yeast is usually sold in sachets or small tins. It’s important to ensure the sachet or tin is sealed properly after each use, and stored in the fridge after opening. Once opened, use the yeast within two to three months – using expired yeast can leave you with an inedible loaf (trust me, I’ve tried).

Some machines come with automatic yeast dispensers, while others require you to place the yeast in the baking pan. In the latter case, it’s best to add yeast first or last, so that flour prevents it from coming into contact with the liquid too soon. If this were to happen, your loaf may not rise enough. This is particularly important when a delay timer is used.

Breadmaker tips

The balance of ingredients

It’s crucial to measure out the correct amount of ingredients; follow any recipe closely.

For example, adding some salt helps to strengthen the gluten, while too much salt can kill the yeast. Sugar nourishes the yeast, so a small amount of it will be consumed by the yeast during the fermentation process – but too much sugar can result in an overly brown loaf. Not enough liquid in your dough can lead to a dense, flat loaf, but too much may leave your bread full of cavities, cause it to rise too much, or even sink in the middle.

You can find some recipes and advice on the right flour and yeast balance in our breadmaker recipe guide (INSERT LINK HERE).

Breadmaker tips

Temperature

It’s best to keep all your ingredients at room temperature, unless otherwise specified in the recipe. Using liquid that’s too warm will kill the yeast. While there’s also a general warning about adding fridge-temperature liquids – your bread may not rise as well – it’s best to err on the side of coolness rather than attempt to heat up any refrigerated ingredients, such as dairy.

Room temperature and humidity are also factors – although they’d only affect the bread in extreme cases. Some breadmakers, such as the Panasonic SD-ZP2000, purport to measure the ambient temperature and self-regulate during the baking process.

Breadmaker tips

Machine basics

Your results will of course depend on your breadmaker, so check out our guide to the Best bread makers. But regardless of the model, you’re likely to be using a machine with a baking pan and detachable kneading blade.

To avoid spilling anything inside the breadmaker, you should remove the bread pan from the machine. I find it easiest to place the pan on the scales and weigh the ingredients that way. But make sure your kneading blade is in place beforehand. Getting it in there once you’ve added the flour is messy at best; at worst you’ll be coming back to a bread that hadn’t mixed or baked properly – which is disappointing.

Finally, remember to remove the bread from the pan soon after baking. Otherwise, the bread can turn soggy and even collapse due to excess moisture. Kneading blades can sometimes become stuck in the loaf – make sure to cut it out carefully before slicing. Some machines, such as the Swan SB1041N QuickBake, come with a hook to remove the blade; any sharp, thin object will be helpful here.

Breadmaker tips

Breadmaker programs

Breadmakers normally have a selection of programs that come with pre-set baking times, although some also boast customisable functions. In general, it’s best to follow through with a program, unless you’ve noticed that the designated time leaves a loaf under- or overdone.

As for which setting to use, it depends on your recipe. Usually there are programs for white, wholewheat, gluten-free and “quick” or “rapid” bread at the very least. The “quick” or “rapid” setting cuts the baking time in half – but this means your dough will have less time to rise and more yeast needs to be added. In my testing experience, the pricier breadmakers are usually more successful at this, with little difference between loaves, while budget options may struggle a bit.

Most breadmakers have a program called “bake-only” or “cake”, which doesn’t involve kneading or proving. You’d normally also find a program that anticipates the addition of dried fruit, nuts or other small chunks. Some breadmakers beep to let you know when to add these other ingredients – others have an automatic dispenser. More premium breadmakers can include programs for brioche, sourdough and rye bread.

Breadmaker tips

Additional functions

Most breadmakers aren’t just limited to baking loaves and loaf cakes; they often include other functions. A program for making dough can be used for anything from bread rolls and buns to focaccia and pizza bases. You may also choose to prepare your bread dough in the machine, then shape it by hand, leave it to rise until double the size and thereafter baking it in a traditional oven. This will give you greater control over the appearance of the loaf.

Dough prepared in a breadmaker doesn’t need to be used right away. It can be refrigerated in an airtight container for up to 24 hours. Just bear in mind that despite the cold, the dough will continue rise, so you should leave some space for it in the container. Once it’s out of the fridge, the dough should be punched down and left to rest for a while at room temperature.

While the majority of dough recipes are suitable to be made in the machine, it’s advisable to adhere to the minimum amounts of flour recommended as per your manufacturer’s instructions. If you’re using very little ingredients, they may not get mixed and kneaded properly in a large baking pan. Here’s a selection of dough recipes you can make in a breadmaker.

Another popular function with breadmakers is a jam program – simply add sugar and chopped fruit or berries (and some powdered pectin, if you like your jam firm). Check out these recipes for summer fruit, apricot and blueberry jams.

Other possible programs include yoghurt – a 10-hour process available on the Morphy Richards Homebake – as well as pasta, as seen on the Panasonic SD-ZX2522.

Unlike other sites, we thoroughly review everything we recommend, using industry standard tests to evaluate products. We’ll always tell you what we find. We may get a commission if you buy via our price links. Tell us what you think – email the Editor