Home / Computing / Laptop / Microsoft Surface Book

Microsoft Surface Book review

By

Updated:

Awards

  • Recommended by TR

1 of 11

Microsoft Surface Book video review
  • Microsoft Surface Book video review
  • Surface Book
  • Surface Book
  • Surface Book
  • Surface Book
  • Surface Book
  • Surface Book
  • Surface Book
  • Surface Book
  • Surface Book
  • Surface Book

Summary

Our Score:

8

Pros

  • Great performance
  • Optional Nvidia GPU
  • Sharp and vibrant screen
  • Solid build quality
  • Windows 10 as it should be

Cons

  • Spongy keyboard
  • Very, very, very expensive
  • Screen isn't set up for serious design work

Key Features

  • Bundled keyboard dock and Surface Pen
  • Optional secondary NVIDIA GeForce GPU
  • Intel Core i5 or i7 CPU
  • 13.3-inch PixelSense display
  • 8GB or 16GB RAM
  • 8-megapixel rear, 5-megapixel front cameras
  • Manufacturer: Microsoft
  • Review Price: £1,300.00

Buy Now: Surface Book at Amazon.co.uk (£1,295) | Amazon.com ($1,349)

What is the Surface Book?

Microsoft’s Surface range of tablets has steadily been growing a following since the US powerhouse started shipping the devices in 2012.

The 2015 Microsoft Surface Pro 4 offered top-end specifications within a neat portable design and is, in my opinion, the ultimate productivity tablet at the moment. However, its usability as a laptop is marred by its lack of a dedicated GPU and bundled keyboard – the Type Cover keyboard accessory still costs over £100 more.

The Surface Book, on paper, fixes these flaws, and is being marketed by Microsoft as a laptop first and a tablet second. But with pricing for the most basic version starting at £1300, can it justify its hefty upfront cost?

Update: Since my original review, some of the software issues I encountered have been solved through various patches. However, because I don't have a Surface Book to test them out on, I can only point you to the Microsoft Surface Book update history page to see what Microsoft has been up to.

Most recently, Microsoft has launched its brand-new Surface Laptop, which is now the the cheapest way to get into the Microsoft laptop ecosystem. With a soft-touch fabric keyboard tray and an attractive design starting at under a grand, it's looking very tempting. It's not a replacement to the top-end Surface Books with dedicated graphics chips, but it does seem like a better value choice than the lower-specification Surface Books.

My original review from February 2016 continues below.

Check out our video review of the Surface Book

Related: Best laptops 2016

Surface Book – Design

Since the Surface Pro 3, Microsoft’s really come into its own on the design front, which is why I’m pleased it hasn’t rocked the boat too much with the Surface Book.

From a distance you’d be forgiven for mistaking the tablet section of the Surface Book for the Surface Pro 4. The device’s chassis is built of the same grey magnesium, with the only obvious design feature being a shiny Windows logo on its back.

Up close, however, you’ll notice a few key changes. For starters, it's a little larger than the Pro 4, measuring in at 7.7mm thick and 312 mm wide – dimensions that place it in roughly the same size bracket as a 13-inch Macbook.

Microsoft’s also ditched the Pro 4’s kickstand to make way for the Surface Book’s biggest feature – its detachable keyboard dock. Unlike past Surface models, the Book comes bundled with a full-on physical keyboard, not relying on an optional Type Cover.

Related: Everything you need to know about the Microsoft Surface Pro 5

Surface Book

The keyboard houses the Surface Book’s most interesting feature: an optional secondary NVIDIA GeForce GPU. The GPU activates when the tablet section is docked in the keyboard, and in theory will radically improve performance. When undocked the Surface Book’s tablet section runs using the lower-power Intel HD graphics.

The dock also houses the Surface Book’s primary battery and the lion’s share of its ports – a point that further emphasises the focus on being a laptop first, tablet second. Ports-wise, the Surface Book is pretty well stocked when you consider its tiny dimensions. Along the dock’s sides you’ll find two USB 3.0 ports, an SD card reader, a Mini DisplayPort, a headphone jack and a proprietary charging socket.

The sleak dimensions and wealth of connectivity options make the Surface Book feel unashamedly premium and, in my mind, one of the nicest-looking convertibles around.

Surface Book – Keyboard and Trackpad

The physical keyboard is another neat addition. I personally didn’t have an issue with the Surface Pro 4’s Type Cover, but understand many did. For starters, the Type Covers are paper thin and aren’t weighted, which meant using a Pro 4 on your lap is something of a balancing act. Many people also didn’t click with the touchpad, feeling they were too small and slightly unresponsive.

By comparison the Surface Book’s backlit keyboard is an entirely physical, metal affair, more akin to Asus Transformer Books’ docks than past Type Covers. The keyboard is a definite step up and offers a significantly improved typing experience. This is largely down to the keys' improved travel and spacing.

Surface Book

The more comfortable typing experience is aided by the Surface Book keyboard's intelligent hinge. The hinge has been designed to evenly adjust the Surface Book’s weight balance to ensure it doesn’t become top heavy, irrespective of the screen’s angle. The design works a treat and means it's one of the most lap-friendly convertibles around.

My only issue with the keys is that they aren’t quite as tactile as I’d like, compared to, say, the Asus Transformer Book T300 Chi or Dell XPS 12. With prolonged or rapid typing the keys feel a little spongy and aren’t quite as reactive as I’d like – though, being fair to Microsoft, this is an issue I have with most laptops and convertibles.

The trackpad’s also been improved. As well as being larger, the glass-finished pad feels more responsive and accurate than its Type Cover siblings. Two finger gestures work a treat and in general I have no issues using it.

Surface Book – Display

The Surface Book’s screen has also had a modest makeover. Microsoft’s increased the Surface Book’s PixelSense screen size to 13.3 inches, making it over an inch bigger than the Surface Pro 4’s.

For general consumers the screen is brilliant. The 3,000 x 2,000 resolution and 267ppi pixel density mean icons and text are constantly sharp. Brightness levels and viewing angles are stellar and I didn’t notice any backlight bleed.

Cracking out my trusty colorimeter, I found the Surface Book’s screen also to be well calibrated. The 1,750:1 contrast ratio I recorded is great and means the screen can display suitably nice deep and inky blacks alongside clear, unmuddied whites.

Surface Book

The 6,377K colour temperature I recorded is less than 200K away from the 6,500K ideal – meaning colours don’t look overcooked or too cool to the naked eye. The Surface Book’s 0.19 Delta E is stellar – any score floating around or below 1.0 indicates excellent colour accuracy. The screen’s 94.3% sRGB colour gamut coverage is above average, and more than wide enough to meet general users' needs.

My only issue with the Surface Book’s screen is its average coverage of the Adobe RGB colour gamut. For non-techie folks, the Adobe RGB is a standard used by many creative professionals that dictates the range of colours a screen can accurately display. As a rule of thumb any serious art or photography display should cover 90% or above of the Adobe RGB. The Surface Book only covers 67.6% of the Adobe RGB.

Being fair, Microsoft’s never made any claims about the Surface Book’s Adobe RGB coverage, but when you consider the fact that it’s marketing the device as “ideal for creatives” I’m still a little disappointed. Hopefully Microsoft will fix this issue with its next wave of Surfaces.

Paul

February 18, 2016, 6:32 pm

smells like another lustful apple victory

Prem Desai

February 18, 2016, 6:38 pm

Why on earth are you talking about Apple on a Microsoft product review - to which Apple has no competition.

It has not been pitched against ANY Apple product, so how could it be an Apple victory??

Something does smell - and it's you!

Paul

February 18, 2016, 6:41 pm

i see you edited.

good boy.

and everyday is a good day for apple, not even the fbi can **** with them

Coburn_Alpha

February 19, 2016, 8:55 am

He's an Apple troll. does it all the time

Paul

February 19, 2016, 5:33 pm

shut up shitty arse

eaglesgift

February 20, 2016, 10:04 am

It's really funny to see people act like football supporters over large corporations whose only interest is taking as much of our money as they possibly can. Do you realise how ridiculous you sound?

Solomon Steve

March 25, 2016, 5:14 pm

Paul, infact u are a stupid fool

F J

April 3, 2016, 11:45 pm

How did the touchpad only get a 8/10? Its the best touchpad I have used on a windows device. Its not far from the Macbooks if not its on par,

MotorMouth

April 17, 2016, 5:13 am

The review mentions the screen's poor coverage of the Adobe RGB spectrum. It failed to point out that the Adobe RGB colour space is only useful for people dealing with print and that for professionals who work in TV, video, film or web graphics, the sRGB gamut is far more important, which is probably why the display covers most of it.

Matt Williams

July 29, 2016, 10:39 am

It is a good touchpad but my wife won't let me use it in bed because the left and right clicks wake her up.

F J

July 29, 2016, 10:41 am

I can totally agree with you on that. Loud clicks no matter where you press it. You could always tap to select, but that defeats the purpose of having the ability to click it.

Alastair J. Archibald

August 24, 2016, 2:38 pm

Well, I've been looking for travelling laptop Nirvana for what seems like forever, I've tried iPads 1, 2, Mini and Air, MacBook Air and MacBook Pro, Surface Pro 2 and Surface Pro 4. I thought for a while I'd reached it with the SP4, but the Type Pad keyboard wasn't fast enough for me (I write novels semi-professionally) and the touchpad left a bit to be desired.

Now with the Surface Book 1TB + GPU, I am there. The touchpad is the best I've ever met possibly apart from the MBP's version. The keyboard lets me type at my full speed for hour after hour. The visuals are gorgeous, much nicer than Apple's frankly outdated Retina display. Multitasking is great with 16GB of RAM, and the GPU is OK for XCOM 2 at reasonable frame rates when I am relaxing.

Peter Wright

January 23, 2017, 8:41 pm

I have had a love hate relationship with this machine for 6 months now. It is great when it works. That is less than when it does. The keyboard regularly stops working. bringing the Book back from standby often ends in hang up. This requires a hard reboot hanging on to the power and volume keys for 30, yes 30 seconds.
I wanted to use it for yacht race navigation and after it failed and I had to use my smartphone to keep a million pound superyacht off the rocks, I can no longer trust it. It stays ashore as we are not allowed useless weight aboard.
I spilt a couple of drops of water onto the keyboard. The ampersand and apostrophe keys (wouldnt it be great to save 15 keystrokes) stopped working. Mia culpa and on to the phone to Microsoft because no-one else can fix them. The want £500 yes FIVE HUNDRED FEKKIN QUID , half the cost of the machine to fix it. Well I now have half a laptop and a very expensive tablet.
Microsoft have an arrogant attitude to their customers and their over rated, overpriced equipment. I have gone back to my HP laptop and the next laptop will cost less than a Microsoft repair. Buy this at your peril.

Scott

June 16, 2017, 7:21 pm

Yes so they have to work hard to get peopl this fired up about them. Microsoft always wins btw. Also are football teams not trying to take money from you? (Tickets, advertising, apparel, etc...)

comments powered by Disqus