Home / Product Round-ups / Printers / Best Printer 2016: The best inkjets and lasers for the home and office

Best Printer 2016: The best inkjets and lasers for the home and office

by

BestPrinters

We take a look at the best printers we've reviewed, scouring our vast archive of inkjet and laser printer reviews on the hunt for the best printers for quality, running costs and features.

Printing is very much still alive, as is demonstrated by the sheer variety of printers you can buy these days. There's something for every budget, with our cheapest printer here starting at just £35. You get what you pay for and, as prices increase, so do the number of features.

As you'll see from our buying guide below, you can mix and match the features you want and usually get a great deal. There isn't a lot a £100 printer can't do, so above that point you're getting into specialist territory with exceptional print quality and more unusual features.

Read on to see what turns a good printer into a great one, and how to choose the best printer for your needs.

This Week's Best Printer Deals

Laser – Dell S2810dn at Amazon.co.uk | Was £155 | Now £74.99

Inkjet – Epson WorkForce WF-7110DTW at Amazon.co.uk | Was £179 | Now £113

InkJet – Brother MFC-J4620DW at Amazon.co.uk | Was £167 | Now £121

Laser – HP Color LaserJet Pro M252dw at Amazon.co.uk | Was £174.99 | Now £149.99

Best Printer Buyer's Guide

Laser vs inkjet – As has been the case for the many years, the single biggest consideration when buying a printer for a home or small office is whether it's a laser or inkjet device.

With laser, the powdered ink (toner) is essentially melted into the paper, which makes it far more resilient and resistant to running. Laser printers are also far quicker once they've warmed up, so are better suited to high-volume work.

The downside is that they're more expensive than inkjets if you're after a model that can print in colour. While you can pick up a colour inkjet for less than £30, you’ll struggle to find a colour laser printer for less than £100.

Also, the quality of colour prints isn’t a patch on inkjet. As such, colour lasers aren't really any good for photos, but rather are useful for printing documents with colour charts and the like.

A new tweak on the laser printer is the LED printer, which works in essentially the same way but replaces the laser with an LED.

As for inkjets, their big advantage is that colour models are available for pretty reasonable prices, and even the cheap ones are capable of printing decent photos. So if you’re looking to purchase only one printer for all your household needs then an inkjet remains the best bet.

Modern inkjets are also significantly faster than ever before. The past few years has seen a rise in the market of office-orientated inkjets, which can print reasonably quickly without foregoing print quality.

Finally, there are also the very latest models that use a paper-width print head, rather than a small print head that scans back and forth. Only available in high-end machines, they're ideal for those demanding really high print speeds and top-notch quality.

Ink types – Inkjets also come in a number of different types, with different jet technologies (piezo or thermal) and ink types (aqueous dye and pigment, solvent, UV-curable and dye sublimation). However, what will matter for most home and small-business buyers is the distinction between dye and pigment-based inks. Canon MAXIFY MB2050 - Cartridges

Dye-based inks tend to be cheaper and produce good-quality prints, but they’re prone to fading with exposure to UV light. As with all aqueous (water-based) inks, they’ll also run if wet.

While pigment-based inks will also run if wet, they don’t fade as quickly. As such, they’re sometimes marketed as “archival quality”, and they’re often more expensive too.

The complication here is that it isn't always clear what type of printer uses what type of ink. For the most part, most black inks are pigmented, while most colours are dye-based. However, high-end photo printers will use only pigment-based inks to ensure long-lasting prints.

Print heads – Another thing to look out for with inkjets is whether the replacement cartridge includes the print head or whether it’s only the ink.

With the former, there's the advantage of ensuring that you get a new print head with every cartridge change. However, such cartridges tend to be more expensive.

Cartridges that are just the ink are cheaper, but with this comes the risk that the fixed print head in the printer will eventually clog up and image quality will drop as a result. In fact, you also need to consider that the head might eventually fail completely. HP LaserJet Pro MFP M125nw - Cartridge

Canon, HP and Lexmark mostly uses cartridges with new print heads, while Epson models tend to use fixed print heads.

Dedicated photo printers – While normal inkjets can print pretty decent-quality photos, they have their limitations. As such, there are also more specialised printers available on the market. These use more than the usual four inks (black, cyan, magenta and yellow), with the extra shades allowing for finer colour gradations and punchier colours.

Inevitably, such printers are more expensive up front, but they can be cheaper in the long-run since they tend to have larger-capacity print cartridges. So, if photo-printing is high on your priority list then they’re definitely worth considering.

All-in-one? – Once you’ve chosen the type of printer you want, the next question to ask is whether you want it to be anything more than just a printer. While there are a number of miscellaneous extra features that certain models may feature, the three big ones are duplex, scanning and fax.

Duplex is where the printer can print on both sides of the paper, so you don’t have to manually print only the odd pages then return the paper to the paper tray to print only the even pages. Some printers have duplex built in, while many offer it as an add-on. Either way, it tends to be a feature that's available only on the higher-end models.HP Deskjet 1510 - Open

As for scanning and faxing, they tend to appear together in what are dubbed all-in-one printers. The scanner can either be a flatbed type that allows you to scan anything, from books to bottoms, or sheet-fed models where you can feed in only fairly thin materials such as single sheets of paper. Along with a basic scan facility, such printers may also have a “photocopy” mode.

Due to their scanning abilities, many all-in-ones also include a fax facility, allowing you to scan and send off documents directly, without the need for a computer at all.

Extra features – The single most useful extra on a printer is network connectivity, whether that be via a cable (Ethernet) or Wi-Fi. That said, many routers these days include a printer server facility that allows you to plug any USB printer into the router and have it share the printer throughout your home network. Whichever way you make it work, it's really convenient to be able to print from any computer in the home.

Another feature to look out for is a card reader. These allow you to print directly from the memory card from your camera. Many of us always prefer to tweak photos before printing them, but if that doesn't interest you then an built-in reader is an easy way to speed things up. Also, some printers can even talk directly to certain cameras via the PictBridge standard.

Paper size – The vast majority of printers for home and small business deal only in A4 paper or smaller, so those wishing to print on larger paper will have to seek out such functionality. Even then, most larger format printers still only go up to A3 size, with even larger sizes requiring you to invest in serious high-end machines.

Not surprisingly, the larger paper format means that A3-capable printers are more expensive, although it's still possible to pick one up for as little as £50.

Paper type – A final bit of general advice for printers is to ensure that you buy paper that’s appropriate for what you’re printing. The basic stuff will do fine for churning out numerous black-and-white pages, but if you’re planning to send out CVs, for example, then it’s worth using decent, thicker paper.

Meanwhile, photo-printing will only work well on proper, glossy photo paper. What’s more, it's worth buying the right paper for your type of printer ink, too (manufacturers often recommend paper), since the paper is actually formulated to match the combination of ink types used in that printer.

John Tropi

May 6, 2016, 3:46 pm

That was an excellent, well written article.
Just one point though, regarding running cost comparisons of ink-jets with lasers. It is all too common that infrequently used ink-jet cartridges dry up, beyond all recovery, when not used for a while. This is not only infuriating, but horrendously expensive. The unavoidable replacement of barely used and over-priced ink cartridge can very easily outweigh other considerations in overwhelming favour of buying a low end laser model instead. I would greatly welcome a thorough discussion of this point, including point blank contradiction! But please give your reasoning. This NEEDS thrashing out.

Recognizing_Truth

May 8, 2016, 7:28 pm

i have had terrible luck with HP inkjets over the years - new cartridges print great and can accommodate idle periods of a few days. But after a few weeks, the ink leaving it idle causes the ink to clog the printhead resulting in blotches, streaks and missing lines of pixels. A full cleaning will waste a lot of ink and cure the problem for the immediate session, but the problem quickly returns.
I haven't personally owned an Epson in some years, but a couple friends do and have the same problem, although the deep cleaning lasts longer before re-clogging. My Canon MX850 on the other hand, has never had a problem, even when it sits idle for extended periods of time. FWIW.

GeriP

June 2, 2016, 7:22 pm

Before you buy an HP printer, check the forums and see what some of the problems are. I wish I had done that. I purchased a 5530 back in November, not knowing that there has bee an ongoing issue with the printing of booklets. Customers have been contacting support for some two years now over what is clearly an issue with the design of the driver and the problem still hasn't been fixed. Just got a message from someone on another forum who let me know that driver problems exists with a lot of the more recent printer drivers, and it seems that they will no longer support the older ones that actually worked. I bought a second HP printer because the first one, a 4480 that I got back in 2009 worked so well, right up until HP decided that they would no longer support the printer and shut it down themselves through the internet, after sending me that little message (I probably shouldn't have signed up to HP support).

Ed

June 6, 2016, 4:09 pm

Thanks. Regarding the inkjet idle issue, I've had the same ink cartridges in my HP printer (which itself is the better part of ten years old) for well over a year and it's only ever used sporadically (once a week at most) and they're still going strong. That said, I'll certainly do a bit more research on this issue.

John Tropi

June 6, 2016, 6:58 pm

Cheers Ed.
Once a week isn't infrequent enough to be any kind of a problem. When I was busier, I did not have any problems either. I'm not sure what the critical timing would be. These days, ours often spends a couple of months idle and I've had cartridges dry out that had only printed half a dozen pages. That is serioUsly expensive! I think a laser would have proved a better buy in these circumstances and I'm thinking about it quite seriously.

Ed

June 6, 2016, 7:06 pm

Hmmm, did you try reinvigorating them by dabbing the print heads with water? Has worked for me in the past. Otherwise, if they're completely dried up then, as you suggest, a laser may be the only solution.

John Tropi

June 7, 2016, 4:28 pm

That's an excellent tip Ed!

I have done it - sometimes it works, sometimes, unfortunately, not.

TallyHo!

June 26, 2016, 2:58 pm

I've had my HP Deskjet 1050 for years. Cost me about £30 from Argos and never let me down. Simple, cheap and more than adequate for a home office.

aswad manap

September 1, 2016, 1:16 am

I am glad that founded this review for choosing the right printer after all. Just to get to know that maybe you can separate it to two categories which are laserjet and inkjet for easier the comparison purpose.

themanwhocan

September 17, 2016, 1:04 pm

One thing overlooked with extra features is that the software (interface) accompanying the printer to make good use of those features is half-baked or not intuitive nor fit for purpose. Many low end laser printers (I own a Samsung) suffer from inkjet running costs and poor software/firmware. Something for future reviews should also look into these aspects particularly when it comes to scanning.

My question is does file type make a difference in terms of running cost. For example: if I scan a letter twice and convert one into PDF and the other as a jpeg, do they use same amount of ink or does one use more. Does the printer treat both as images or applies different criteria.

fordingbridge

September 21, 2016, 9:38 am

Clearly the 'boycott HP' campaign means nowt to you

comments powered by Disqus