Everything is smarter these days, but the thermostat market has really benefited from the upgrade. Being able to program your thermostat to turn or off at specific times and locations can save you a lot of cash. Winters no longer have to be hideously expensive.
Out of the range of smart thermostats that we’ve tested, two stand out in particular. The Honeywell Evohome is the ultimate choice, giving you room-by-room control thanks to its radiator valves. If you’re on a tight budget, the Netatmo Smart Thermostat is an excellent choice, and it can be expanded with its own radiator valves at a later date.
How we pick the best smart thermostats
The only way to truly compare smart thermostats is to have one person review them under the same conditions, something that Trusted Reviews is capable of. We wire all of our smart thermostats into an electric radiator, testing performance over a period of weeks in a single room. That lets us see how each thermostat performs and how it learns to adjust its settings to suit the room, giving us an accurate way of comparing each model. For smart radiator valves, we have a traditional hot water radiator in the same room, which we attach the valve to, giving us a proper comparison between rival systems.
Usability is key when testing smart thermostats, so we test how easy it is to programme schedules on each. Beyond that, we test the more advanced features for reliability, such as geolocation, which will automatically turn off your heating as you go out, and turn it back on as you return home.
Increasingly, the ability for smart thermostats to talk to other devices and voice assistants is becoming more important. Our testing environment includes Amazon Echo and Google Home smart speakers, and an iPad for Apple HomeKit compatibility. We also test the IFTTT integration, if available, and how the system interacts with other smart home devices, such as through Samsung SmartThings.
- Most comprehensive smart heating solution
- Zones allow incredibly granular control
- Powerful mobile app
- Costs rise rapidly with multiple zones
- Manual scheduling process
- No control via web browser
No company has as much experience in the heating arena as Honeywell. It should be no surprise, then, that the company’s first smart product is so comprehensive. Rather than replacing your basic smart thermostat, the Evohome adds room-by-room control through smart thermostatic radiator valves (TRVs).
Although this adds to the initial setup cost – you’ll need a £59 TRV per radiator – it will be possible to save money thereafter since you’ll only need to heat the rooms you’re using. Also, each room is set to its perfect temperature, making for a much more comfortable home environment.
Honeywell has refined and expanded its system since launch. The smartphone app has improved immeasurably, making it easy to control each room and view the state of your home at-a-glance. In addition, the Evohome has a dedicated touchscreen controller for your home, so you don’t need to reach for your smartphone.
IFTTT support has been added, too, so you can control Evohome via other smart devices. For example, you can set your heating to turn off when you go out using IFTTT, making up for the fact that there’s no integrated presence detection. Amazon Alexa support lets you control the system with your voice, too, as does Google Home support.
Honeywell’s Evohome may be one of the most expensive systems around, but it’s also one of the best – and ideal for larger installations.
Netatmo Smart Thermostat
- Simple to install
- Flexible scheduling
- Easily expandable
- Android app unresponsive on occasion
- Geofencing isn’t integrated
The Netatmo Smart Thermostat is one of the cheapest such systems you can buy, but that doesn’t mean it lacks features. In fact, it’s one of the most flexible heating systems around, and with the launch of smart radiator valves, it’s one you can expand to fit your needs. You can adjust your main heating via the battery-powered E Ink thermostat, which looks gorgeous. Since you can carry it around, it’s possible to keep the room you’re currently using at exactly the right temperature.
A simple smartphone app makes control while at home and away straightforward, with easy scheduling making it possible to keep your home at the right temperature hour-by-hour. There’s no built-in presence detection to switch your heating on and off automatically, but you can add this using IFTTT. More recently, the Smart Radiator Valves let you add room-by-room control, although the integration’s not quite as neat as Evohome’s.
Amazon Alexa, Google Home and Apple HomeKit integration make the Netatmo Smart Thermostat one of the few that can be controlled via the two biggest voice systems. While the thermostat lacks a little polish of more expensive systems have, its low price makes it an enticing prospect.
- Super-stylish design
- Largely intuitive interface
- Great app
- Potentially saves money on gas bill
- Still quite pricey up-front
- Energy savings not guaranteed
- Requires constant power connection
Think of smart thermostats and the Nest Learning Thermostat is likely to be one of the first to spring to mind. That’s for good reason, too, since this is the product that showed how powerful smart heating could be. Now in its third generation, the Nest Learning Thermostat remains one of the best smart thermostats you can buy.
As the name suggests, the thermostat learns how you like your home heated, thereafter creating an automatic schedule for you. Not surprisingly, there’s a bit of a learning curve. In the first few weeks, the Nest may not work quite the way you want it. Over time, however, it should prove to be better than a manually set schedule on another thermostat.
Presence detection lets the thermostat turn on and off automatically, based on whether or not you’re home . The Nest is also brilliant at talking to other devices. Via the Works With Nest program, a variety of other smart devices will work with your smart thermostat. For example, your Philips Hue lights can turn off when you go out. With an excellent IFTTT channel and support for Amazon Alexa and Google Home (HomeKit support doesn’t seem likely), the Nest is one of the best-connected smart thermostats available.
This latest version supports dual-zone plumbing and can be extended to support hot water systems, too. There are no smart radiator valves to add full zoning, however.
Tado Smart Thermostat
- Stylish, Minimalist Design
- Easy setup and intuitive control
- Will save you money
- Wired bridge feels clumsy and range is limited
- Priced closely to bigger rivals
Tado launched with the sole goal of making smart heating systems easy to use, and it certainly succeeded. The Tado Smart Thermostat is designed to track your location so that your heating goes off when you’re out and turns back on when you’re on the way home. It works brilliantly, and has the most reliable presence detection we’ve tested.
Since launch, Tado has updated the apps and web interface to add a new heating scheduler, letting you choose the temperature that you want your home at hour-by-hour. Plus, there are option for when you’re out, picking between maximum savings (with the potential to return to a colder home) or maximum comfort (spending more to keep your home warmer). The app is simple to use, making the Tado Smart Thermostat one of the easiest systems to programme.
Tado’s system is also very flexible. With the launch of the Smart Radiator Thermostats, the system can be as powerful as Evohome. However, Tado’s radiator valves aren’t quite as smart, and the app’s zone handling isn’t quite as easy to use as that of Honeywell.
Throw in Amazon Alexa and Google Home support, IFTTT and HomeKit (via the V3 internet bridge), and Tado’s Smart Thermostat is one of the most powerful available. If you don’t want to buy outright, you can even rent the kit, paying monthly for it.
Hive Active Heating 2
- Classy looks and slick interface
- Simple but powerful app
- Hot water control
- Very robust connectivity
- Thermostat upgrade mainly cosmetic
- Professional installation required (but part of the price)
The original Hive system was rather basic, but all of the stops have been pulled out for the Active Heating 2. The freshly designed thermostat looks fantastic, giving the Nest a run for its money. It’s easier to use, too.
The neat smartphone app makes it simply to set up schedules, and it’s capable of tracking your location, so that your heating activates automatically depending on whether or not you’re at home. There’s hot water support, too.
A recent update adds IFTTT support, so you can finally integrate the Hive with other smart devices. Plus, Hive has a growing infrastructure of its own devices to help you build your own smart home, ranging from motion sensors to the new Hive Active Light smart lightbulbs. A little finesse is required (there’s no dedicated physical switch for the light bulbs, for example), but the add-ons are starting to make Hive a more compelling choice. Amazon Alexa and Google Home support is now available.
If you’re a happy DIYer, you can buy the thermostat for £179 and fit it yourself. Alternatively, you can buy it for £249, which includes professional installation.
Heat Genius Smart Heating System
- Infinitely adjustable room-by-room control
- Smart heating cut-off if a window is opened
- Modular design allows you to build over time
- Ugly hardware
- Expensive with all components
It might look like one of the most basic, but Heat Genius is one of the most advanced smart heating systems in this group. It’s designed to give you room-by-room control of your home via smart radiator TRVs. In this way, you’ll see better savings compared to a smart thermostat only, and more comfortable temperatures in each room.
Heat Genius’ real benefit comes from the range of additional devices that make your home smarter. The Genius Room Sensor, for example, learns when you normally enter a room to create an automatic schedule for you; it also turns off your heating automatically when you leave a room. You can buy optional room thermostats, which take a more accurate temperature reading, particularly if a smart TRV is located behind furniture.
Manual control of the Heat Genius system is possible via the app, which we found to be a little clunky and not quite as smooth as the competition. It’s good to see that IFTTT support has been added, so you can integrate Heat Genius with other devices and add extra features, such as presence detection via your mobile phone. IFTTT support means you can add some control via Amazon Alexa, although a dedicated ‘skill’ would be nice.
Hot water support is available for homes that don’t have a combi boiler. More recently, you can buy smart plugs for controlling other electrical appliances, too.
Slightly ugly hardware, the requirement to have a separate internet bridge, and the high costs once you factor everything in disappoint. However, Heat Genius is incredibly advanced and more customisable than rival systems.
Those are our top picks of the best smart thermostats. If you want to know more about how smart thermostats work and what to look out for when buying one, read on.
Best smart thermostats – What are the benefits?
Thanks to more advanced scheduling and the ability to learn how your home heats up, smart thermostats are more efficient than regular models and can save you a fortune in heating bills. Plus, by offering remote control via a smartphone app, you can turn your heating on or off, no matter where you are – which is great if you’re heading off on holiday and suddenly realise that your heating is still on at full power.
Best smart thermostats – What type do I need?
There are numerous smart thermostats to choose from, each offering a variety of features, so it’s important to pick the one that suits your lifestyle and home.
First, you need to consider the type of heating system you want. A regular smart thermostat, such as the 3rd-gen Nest Learning Thermostat, simply replaces your existing thermostat. Although you’ll still save money with such a system, it will be your heating settings that control your entire home.
With a zoned heating system, such as the Honeywell Evohome, you get room-by-room control via smart thermostatic radiator valves (TRVs). Such a system will save you even more money since you’ll be heating only the areas you’re using at any given time. The downside is that the initial outlay for such systems can be costly: typically around £50 to £70 per radiator. They’re a better option for houses with a greater number of rooms to control.
Best smart thermostats – What control options are there?
All smart thermostats should be controllable, to a degree, from the main unit as well as a dedicated smartphone app. Voice control is becoming a more important feature, in the form of Alexa on the Amazon Echo or Siri using Apple HomeKit. Being able to simply tell your thermostat to turn the heating up or down is a convenient way to control the temperature in your home. Alexa support is more widespread, with HomeKit support lagging since Apple requires that kit has a built-in encryption chip.
In addition, there are thermostats that offer presence detection via a smartphone. The models that do this well – the Tado, for example – can automatically turn off the heat when everyone is out, and turn it back on when the first person returns home. Again, this can lead to huge cost savings, as you’ll no longer be paying for heating that nobody is around to enjoy.
IFTTT support allows you to integrate other devices with your smart heating system. For example, you can use Tado’s presence detection to enable a smart camera to turn on automatically; or you can make your heating turn off automatically when the temperature outside hits a certain point. The combinations are almost limitless.
Do you have another product you’d recommend? Let us know on Twitter @TrustedReviews