- Quick and quiet AF
- Poor retro compatibility
- Review Price: £280
Nikon’s flagship f/1.4 50mm standard lens sits alongside the D-series version and, though the two products are similar, there are some crucial differences. Being a G-series lens there is no aperture ring here, so if you need manual control and/or Automatic Indexing then you should choose the D-series lens instead. The G’s focusing ring is also lower-geared than on the D-series lens, so the latter will probably score on that front too.
The G-series lens, however, wins hands-down when it comes to AF speed and quietness, but very occasionally it recorded real-world images that were very slightly less sharp than the others on test here. This is not a serious problem but it was detected on isolated occasions.
Although there is a focused-distance window it is distinctly small and the depth-of-field markings, for f/11 and f/16, are absolutely tiny. Both these problems could be resolved if Nikon chose not to emblazon the lens name right across the middle of the barrel. As is often the case, the supplied lens hood can be reversed and stowed backwards on the lens but this would restrict access and degrade handling so many users will probably elect to store the two parts separately.
Technical testing produced some impressive resolution figures but with a slight lack of smoothness in the MTF curve. The latter may simply have been due to the fact that the curve is very flat and thus reveals irregularities more than would be seen with a greater variation in gradient. Still, the resolution figures were always above the critical 0.25 cycles-per-pixel level, and chromatic aberrations were virtually non-existent.
The G-series f/1.4 lens performed just as well on the DX-format D80 body as it did on the full-frame D700, suggesting that it delivers consistent performance right across the image field.
The D-series lens might offer marginally better resolution but most buyers will probably prefer the G-series lens on account of its internal focusing and superior AF drive.
Score in detail
Image Quality 10
Unlike other sites, we thoroughly test every product we review. We use industry standard tests in order to compare features properly. We’ll always tell you what we find. We never, ever accept money to review a product. Tell us what you think - send your emails to the Editor.