- Peak resolution
- Some colour fringing
- Review Price: £795
* Constant f/2.8 aperture
* Fast AF with internal focussing
* 3.3x zoom range
* Image stabilisation system
* Compatible with E-TTL II flashguns
Canon’s APS-C format 17-55mm zoom is the most expensive of four
lenses that cover the same format and share approximately the same focal-length
range. Its stable-mates are zooms with headline specifications of 15-85mm
f/3.5-5.6, 18-55mm f/3.5-5.6 and 17-85mm f/4-5.6: these lenses have SRPs of
£900, £220 and £600 respectively against the 17-55mm’s SRP of £1210. The price
difference is largely due to the 17-55mm’s wider maximum aperture (f/2.8, constant
across the focal-length range). Inevitably, therefore, maximum-aperture
performance is bound to come under close scrutiny – see below.
This is a fairly heavy lens (645g) that feels solid and
well-built. It nestles nicely in the hand and has a broad, short-throw zoom
ring that occupies most of the front half of the lens barrel. There is a
smaller manual-focussing ring to the rear and a focussed-distance window at the
back of the lens with sliders below to set the focussing mode and to activate
the image stabilisation (IS) system.
Automatic focussing is brisk, accurate and quiet. It is also
internal, so the user’s grip is not compromised by having to keep fingers clear
of the focussing ring. Better still, when manual focusing is required the ring
is within immediate third-finger reach without requiring any significant change
of balance. Both rings offer just the right amount of resistance and it is
probably fair to say that, ergonomically, this is one of the best designed
lenses to have been tested for WDC’s lens reviews.
The IS system is said to allow exposures that are three
times longer than usual without any visible blurring. Practical tests suggest
this claim is very realistic. Less encouraging were the clear colour fringes
that could be seen under taxing conditions (both real-world and technical
testing) when the lens was used at short focal-length settings.
Image sharpness, however, was very good and peak resolution
was excellent. Between f/5.6 and f/11 the zoom achieved either better than or
close to 0.3 cycles-per-pixel but there was a clear decline thereafter and
wide-aperture performance at the 55mm setting was also disappointing. Image
distortion, on the other hand, was very well controlled right across the zoom
Peak resolution is good at all focal lengths but it is a
shame that wide-aperture performance at the 55mm setting was a little weak. Similarly,
at the other end of the aperture range sharpness also rolls-off through f/16
Overall this is a very good lens. It is well specified and the combination of a 17mm minimum focal length a maximum aperture of f/2.8 is especially impressive. The zoom is fully compatible with Canon E-TTL II flashguns in respect of transferring distance information to help ensure optimal exposures. Build quality and handling both inspire confidence and an on-the-street price tag of under £800 makes this a very affordable lens. The only real down-sides are wide-aperture sharpness at 55mm and the appearance of colour fringes under some conditions. Even so this is still a very capable lens that deserves close attention from users of Canon APS-C bodies.
Score in detail
Image Quality 9
Unlike other sites, we thoroughly test every product we review. We use industry standard tests in order to compare features properly. We’ll always tell you what we find. We never, ever accept money to review a product. Tell us what you think - send your emails to the Editor.