In addition, it’s a game that’s hard to get your teeth into. As a single encounter with any sort of baddie is enough to send you back to the Retry menu, any progress you make can be lost in a fraction of a second. Admittedly, this adds to the game’s addictive strengths, but at times it feels more than a little unfair. Sudden attacks from bombing bears when you have just hit the 3,000 metre mark are enough to cause a hideous outburst of profanity on the train into work. It’s the game that ASBOs were made for.
All the same, I can’t help loving it. Maybe it’s the presentation; the way that, like Yoshi’s Island, it creates its own strange world of wobbly edges and crayon colors, ludicrously cheerful music and childishly gleeful sound effects. Maybe I just can’t stop coming back to reclaim my spot in Marathon mode, or because the multiplayer versus mode – only one copy needed if you want to play against a friend – is also a lot of fun. But mostly, it has to be the game’s sheer charm. Just when you think you’re sick and tired of it, you leave it for a day, give it another try, and find yourself captivated once again by its stupid, but oddly brilliant gameplay. This could have been a classic, but let’s forget about what could have been. Should you buy it now? Well, it’s touch and go, but I would.
Nintendo has come up with a brilliant game mechanic, then failed to quite do it justice. The lack of proper single-player game is disappointing, but Yoshi’s old-fashioned arcade strengths should not be underestimated.
Unlike other sites, we thoroughly test every product we review. We use industry standard tests in order to compare features properly. We’ll always tell you what we find. We never, ever accept money to review a product. Tell us what you think - send your emails to the Editor.