- Review Price: £11.00
One of my main duties here at TrustedReviews is to photograph most of the new products that arrive on our doorstep. In a typical day, it’s not unusual for me to take over two hundred shots, and transferring that many photos using the USB1.1 interface on my Canon 10D digital SLR can take rather a long time.
That’s why I was most interested in the latest USB2.0 CompactFlash reader from flash memory specialist PNY Technologies. As well as offering backwards compatibility with USB1.1, USB2.0 can handle transfer rates of up to 480Mbits/sec – that’s equivalent to 60Mbytes/sec.
Of course, this may look good on paper, but the current CompactFlash cards out there are nowhere near sustaining that sort of transfer speed. For example, if a 1x card can only sustain 150Kbytes/sec, a bit of arithmetic tells me that I would need something like a 400x card to take full advantage of the USB2.0 standard.
Anyway, enough about numbers. Lets take a closer look at the actual reader. After converting from Euros to Sterling, the reader costs around £11.33, which to be honest is not exactly going to break the bank. We couldn’t find anywhere stocking it yet, but when stock does hit the channel, you may find it going for even less.
The device itself has a rather plastic feel to it, although it is finished in a stylish silver colour. For those difficult to reach or crowded USB ports, the PNY reader is also supplied with a 1.2m cable. In addition, the reader is compatible with both Type I and Type II CompactFlash memory cards and therefore will happily accommodate IBM’s MicroDrive.
Typically, the memory slot is also keyed so that CompactFlash cards can only be inserted in the correct orientation thereby minimising any possible damage to the reader’s pins or your card. There’s no eject mechanism, so to remove the card all you do is pull it straight out.
If you’re running Windows XP, 2000 or ME this card reader can be used straight out of the box. It’s also compatible with MacOS 8.6 and higher, so Mac owners shouldn’t have any issues. However, if your running Windows 98 you’ll need to install the supplied USB2.0 driver before the reader will be recognised. Once installed, Windows will display the card reader as a removable drive and assign it with a new drive letter.
Transferring files from the card to the PC is then just a matter of dragging and dropping to the desired location on your hard disk – surely a welcome change to those CompactFlash-based devices that use awkwardly designed drivers for file transfer. When plugged in, a green LED stays illuminated until the memory is being accessed (upon which it will start to flicker). As with most USB devices, it’s best to stop the device first using the ‘Unplug or Eject Hardware’ applet in Windows before disconnecting it from your PC. Of course you can rip it straight out, but in my experience this occasionally results in a PC crash or hang.
So far so good, but what about the overall performance? If we take a closer look at the following results it’s clear that the type of memory media used makes a real impact on transfer speed. As with most quoted transfer speeds you’re not always going to get the performance stated on the box. In fact, my high-speed 40x CompactFlash card produced a sustained sequential write speed equivalent to around 30x. Obviously, if you’re limiting yourself to a USB1.1 interface then that standard will affect the transfer times, regardless of the speed rating of the card.
So, as with the majority of USB2.0 card readers, you’re only really held back by the quality and rating of the memory card you use. That said, when using my high-speed card in this reader I did gain about five times more transfer speed in the jump from USB1.1 to 2.0.
All in all, there’s little to fault here, apart from the plastic build quality. Even so, this little reader and the SD version, (priced at around £12) both represent a relatively inexpensive upgrade to USB2.0 – providing your PC supports the standard.
Unlike other sites, we thoroughly test every product we review. We use industry standard tests in order to compare features properly. We’ll always tell you what we find. We never, ever accept money to review a product. Tell us what you think - send your emails to the Editor.