Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon 2015 Review - Keyboard, Trackpad, Options and Verdict Review

Sections

Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon – Keyboard & Trackpad

ThinkPads

come with a certain weight of expectation – not surprising given that

previous machines have possessed some of the market’s best keyboards.

The

Carbon’s slim dimensions haven’t hindered the keyboard’s quality. The

layout makes sense, the keys are large with a nice pronounced dip to

cradle your fingers, and they’ve got more travel than most Ultrabooks.

The good travel is joined by a typing action that’s consistent and

responsive – we’d say it’s a little soft, but it’s a tiny criticism that

won’t impact on day-to-day use.

Lenovo X1 Carbon

The

etched-glass trackpad is fast and consistent, and the two built-in

buttons are snappy. The discrete buttons used for the trackpoint have

familiar ThinkPad reliability, and the point itself is decent; initially

a bit twitchy, but fine after a while.

The keyboard might match

the competition, but the trackpad – as good as it is – is bested by the

Macbook Pro’s Force Touch pad, which is something no Windows laptop can

rival.

Lenovo X1 Carbon

Other things to consider

We’ve

sampled the priciest X1 Carbon specification that costs a whopping

£1,736.99, but cheaper configurations are available. These include

various options with and without touchscreens, with either 1920 x 1080

or 2560 x 1440 resolutions and with different memory and storage

options.

However, the cheapest option is a more manageable

£1,199. For that you get a 1920 x 1080, non-touchscreen display with 4GB

of RAM, a 128GB SSD and an Intel Core i5 5200U processor.

In

comparison the MacBook Air starts at £850, the Dell XPS 13 starts at

£799 and even the MacBook Pro starts at £999. They’re all big savings, but they’re all consumer laptops – so you miss out on Intel vPro, TPM protection and the ThinkPad’s internal access.

The Carbon also comes with a three-year warranty, which is a huge chunk of added value, and important for long-term peace of mind. In fact, it’s so generous we can’t help but wonder if this laptop’s

appeal would be broadened by making this an optional extra and dropping the price by £200 – yup, that’s the cost

of extending a warranty for that long.

Lenovo X1 Carbon

Should I Buy the Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon?

Lenovo’s

latest laptop is impressive in most departments, and its business features give it office appeal that its consumer competitors just can’t match – even if those machines are superior in other areas.

It’s thin, light, well-made and

stylish in its own utilitarian way. However the Dell XPS 13 and MacBook

Air are lighter and slimmer while the Macbook Pro has similar dimensions

but packs in more features and performance. The Lenovo’s screen is sharp and high

quality, but it’s bested by Apple’s machine that has better scaling and

class-leading quality, and the Dell pips the Lenovo in benchmarks.

The

Lenovo machine is faster than the XPS, but it’s slower than the Apple

laptop in application and storage benchmarks, and the Carbon’s otherwise

impressive battery life doesn’t quite match the other two devices.

If you’re after a consumer laptop, then, Dell or Apple’s machines are better options – but the Carbon’s strengths lie in the office. It’s got vPro, TPM and a fingerprint reader, its internals are accessible, and its three-year warranty is generous.

The consistent good quality and extra business features drive up the price, so you’ll have to pay more for this machine than any of its rivals. If you’re after a lightweight business Ultrabook, though, it’s worth that extra money – few machines are better in the boardroom than this. If you’re happy with a consumer laptop, though, save the cash and stick with Apple or Dell.

Verdict

The Carbon is a good laptop

in every department and a big improvement over its predecessor, and it’s packed with business features that its consumer rivals don’t offer – including that generous three-year warranty. That makes it an ideal ultraportable for the office, but its competitors prove superior in some areas: the MacBook Air and Dell XPS 13 are

slimmer, lighter and cheaper while the MacBook Pro offers more

features for similar bulk and a little less cash. If you crave the warranty, TrackPoint and business features, then the Carbon is an excellent office Ultrabook, but if not, the Apple and Dell machines offer better value and balance.

Score


Score in detail

  • Performance 7
  • Keyboard 9
  • Design 8
  • Screen Quality 8
  • Build Quality 9
  • Value 6
  • Touchpad 9
  • Heat & Noise 9
  • Battery Life 8

Unlike other sites, we thoroughly test each product we review. We use industry standard tests in order to compare things properly. We’ll always tell you what we find. We never, ever accept money to review a product. Tell us what you think - send your emails to the Editor.