Palm Foleo: A Needless ‘Smartphone Companion’

A revolutionary new device category or something rather pointless...? Gordon's going with the latter.

I have to admit I’m rather confused…

Today marks the launch of the much rumoured, much hyped ‘Palm Foleo’ and for the life of me I can’t work out why it exists. Apparently the first ‘smartphone companion’ it offers a slim and light laptop form factor (10in LCD, keyboard, Bluetooth, WiFi, 1.13Kg) but without anything like the same functionality.

Instead the Foleo exists primarily to synch with your smartphone (initially a Palm, but Windows Mobile, RiM and Symbian devices in time), enabling users to open their device’s emails and attachments or surf the web on a larger screen using more fully featured clients. Battery life is good for five hours of use and its Linux OS means it can be used on its own as a kind of stripped down laptop.

Ok fine, but I have two major issues here:

1. Isn’t the entire point of a smartphone so that you ”don’t” need to carry a laptop sized device around with you?

2. If you ”are” going to carry a laptop sized device around with you why not carry ”a laptop?”

Yes, the Foleo is cheaper than most slim line laptops at $599 ($499 for a limited time with a $100 in box rebate) but do you really want to own a smartphone, a laptop sized device to synchronise with your smartphone and a laptop to synchronise with your smartphone? Aren’t our lives complicated enough?!

Personally, I can’t think of anything worse than adding yet another device into our lives that requires synchronisation. One laptop, one smartphone, one PC is quite enough thank you and I think most people would agree with me…

Of course I may be completely wrong. Palm founder Jeff Hawkins describes it as “the most exciting product I have ever worked on” but surely – if popular (which it won’t be) – it represents a massive backwards step for an industry which has spent the last few years trying to untie us from our laptops.

And besides, I’m never wrong.

Palm Foleo

Unlike other sites, we thoroughly review everything we recommend, using industry standard tests to evaluate products. We’ll always tell you what we find. We may get a commission if you buy via our price links. Tell us what you think.