Refine search for TVs

Philips Cinema 21:9 56PFL9954H 56in LCD TV Review

Author John Archer
Published 10th Jun 2009
Manufacturer Philips
Price £3,913.04 (Exc VAT)
as reviewed £4,500.00 (Inc VAT)
Latest Price Click here
Design Score 10 for Design
Features Score 10 for Features
Image Quality Score 9 for Image Quality
Sound Quality Score 9 for Sound Quality
Value Score 7 for Value
Overall Score 9 for Overall
Philips Cinema 21:9 56PFL9954H 56in LCD TV
award recommended

Bookmark and Share discuss this article  31 comments    Email  Email trustedreviews newslettersTrustedReviews Newsletters

All this talk of how natural and immersive the Cinema 21:9 experience is would not hold true, of course, if there were significant failings with the processing that makes it all possible. In fact, the stunning naturalness of the 21:9 aspect ratio would make any nasty processing side effects all the more glaring and therefore intolerable.

But provided you take a few simple precautions, the bottom line is that the Cinema 21:9 rescales pictures to take advantage of its unique resolution more cleanly than I'd frankly thought possible.

Rescaled HD sources, for instance (even native 16:9 ratio ones!), still look outstandingly sharp and detailed, with little if any of the softening and edge blurring that often accompanies significant rescaling processes. Colours, meanwhile, lose not a trace of authenticity or accuracy in the rescaling process, overcoming another common rescaling issue. In fact, for my money the Cinema 21:9's colours are among the most natural, subtle yet also superbly vibrant that I've ever seen on a non-LED LCD TV.

Perhaps most remarkable of all is the way the TV manages to add in all the necessary pixels of image data it needs to without making the image look grainy or alive with dot crawl - especially if you keep the contrast setting no higher than 80 and leave on the unusually intelligent noise reduction system (the normal one, not the MPEG one), set to its Low level.


Normally, it must be said, I wouldn't dream of using noise reduction on an HD source, for fear of softening the picture. But the NR system here works beautifully in reducing any slight coarseness that might occur, without substantially reducing the amount of texture and detail in the image.

Add to all the fabulous stuff mentioned so far the fact that the Cinema 21:9 produces some of the deepest black levels I've seen on a Philips LCD screen (not counting its LED model) and suffers remarkably little with motion blur, even without the HD Natural Motion system turned on, and you're talking about the single most cinematic viewing experience I've ever experienced on a telly. Seriously.

While this sort of spectacular HD performance is clearly the Cinema 21:9's bread and butter, it's also a much more able handler of standard definition, 16:9 sources than expected. All but the very lowest quality digital 16:9 broadcasts can be stretched to fill the 21:9 screen with startling aplomb, suffering much less with softness and emphasis of source noise than anticipated. And no, the stretching process doesn't leave everyone on screen looking unfeasibly short and fat!

It's a bit annoying, I guess, that the TV doesn't seem to provide an option that expands 16:9 sources to 21:9 without pushing a bit of the image's top and bottom edges off the screen. And I'd say you're better off leaving poor-quality sources set to their native 16:9 ratio (the option is provided for this) so that they appear with black bars down their left and right sides than trying to push them to the screen's maximum width. But for the most part you really can get ordinary TV shows using all of the TV's pixels without them looking in the least bit nasty.

 

Newsletters

Register to receive the latest Reviews and News Headlines directly to your Inbox every day, and enter our regular competitions. More Info.

Your Name


Email Address


Latest 4 of 31 Comments

Have your say: Leave a comment below about this article.

comment Heinz57 said on 20th June 2009

A word to the wise. Please, please heed Trusted Reviews advise when they say don't seek this TV out if you cant afford it. I stupidly did and really wasn't prepared for h... more

comment David Mackenzie said on 20th August 2009

"And actually, there is no reason at all why Blu-ray manufacturers can't provide a native 21:9, 2,560 x 1,080 version of a 2.35/2.4:1 film on a Blu-ray disc rather than a 16:9... more

comment frankieman said on 11th October 2009

Hi
i am new to this sort of thing and i am buying this tv,does anyone here own one of these,would greatly appreciate any owners comments

comment frankieman said on 22nd October 2009

Just received my tv and i have to say it is superb,in my book worth every penny,just watched one of my old dvds (gladiator)on an upscaling blu ray player and the picture is excelle... more

See all 31 comments on this article.

add comment Add your comment

You must be logged in to comment. Login or register here.