Skylanders - How Does It Play?

By Stuart Andrews

Reviewed:

Summary

Our Score:

7

But what about the game? Well, here’s the surprise. From the screenshots you might be expecting a simple platform adventure, but in fact it’s a weird hybrid of shoot-em-up and action RPG. Each level is broken down into a number of areas and objectives, and these mostly involve blasting the local baddies, collecting dropped loot, solving simple sliding block puzzles – though Skylanders prefers sleepy giant turtles to boring crates – and occasionally using jump pads to hop around.

Blasting baddies nets you experience, and experience means you level up, increasing the damage of your attacks and letting you take a bit more of a beating on top. What’s more, there are collectible hats that give your heroes bonus attributes. The clever thing is that levels, hats and even a nickname are saved to a chip in your plastic figure as you play, meaning you can charge up your Eruptor or Trigger Happy and taken them around to a friend’s house for some co-op action.

If Skylanders disappoints, it’s in the rather limited range of gameplay experiences and the repetitive nature of the levels. While a pirate cove looks different to a giant floating castle, and comes occupied by squid-headed cutthroats instead of weird Cyclops varmints, the actual process of wandering through each level battering the baddies never really changes all that much.

Weapon upgrades can be purchased and used, but only a few of the attacks are really that useful or spectacular. Even the element-specific areas and special challenge missions turn out to be variations on the same few basic themes. Skylanders works as a kind of pre-teen Diablo, and is a lot of fun in co-op mode, but you keep wishing for a little more imagination and exploration – maybe a little more depth.

And while we’re moaning, Skylanders does have the tell-tale look of a game that’s been developed with the Wii as a target then upscaled and polished for the Xbox 360 and PS3. It’s good-looking enough for a family action game, but the latest Lego games, not to mention Sony’s Ratchet and Clank series, have proven that its possible to make something that looks as good as any grown-up blockbuster title. Plus, it would be nice to see a family game that doesn’t get bogged down with dialogue-heavy cut-scenes, even if they’re occasionally well-written and quite funny.

All this is true, but it doesn’t change the fact that Skylanders is slick, addictive and very enjoyable – especially when played in fairly short bursts – or that the whole thing is incredibly appealing to its intended audience. What’s more, there are enough levels and enough replay value in each level to keep that audience busy for some time.

Skylanders also packs in a suite of fun two-player competitive modes, with a crazy top-down variation on arena deathmatch and a whacky sports game starring as the highlights. Add in the way it links in with a secure, child-friendly online world where players can build lairs for their skylanders, explore and enjoy some quirky mini-games, and it’s hard to complain about long-term value. Skylanders is fast becoming a playground phenomenon, and in many ways it deserves to.

Verdict

On paper, Skylanders is an average family game tied in to a brilliant marketing concept, but that doesn’t really do justice to how much fun the whole thing is. The gameplay isn’t anywhere near as inventive or rewarding as it is in the Lego Star Wars/Harry Potter/Pirates series, but its light RPG elements make it more compulsive than it sounds and the whole interaction between toy and game is expertly done. It’s a guaranteed hit with kids, but we suspect a few parents might get sucked in as well.

Overall Score

7

Martin Daler

December 12, 2011, 1:58 pm

Thanks for the warning. To buy a game that does not allow being able to complete the game without being extorted for more cash is something I can do without. If they sold jigsaw puzzles with a few pieces missing, with an included order form and price list to supply the missing pieces, people would see it for the scam that it was. How is this amy different?

Cliff

December 14, 2011, 9:33 pm

I have it on good authority (from my 11 year old son) that you can finish the campaigns, but you have to buy more figures to unlock new levels. Apparently it's an important distiction and he asked me to write back to Martin. Another plus is Patrick Warburton, who does the voice of egotistical ballonist Flynn, who is genuinely funny in the cut-scenes.

Martin Daler

December 15, 2011, 1:12 pm

Thanks Cliff, and thank you to your to your son, clearly a game reviewer in the making! I was almost tempted, until I saw the starting price! 㿛.99 just to get on the bottom rung, before even the ratchet starts its sickening click, click, click. And exactly the same price at Play.com and Amazon - hmm...

comments powered by Disqus