Home / Opinions / Surface Book vs Surface Pro 4

Surface Book vs Surface Pro 4

by

SurfaceBookvsSurface

Surface Book vs Surface Pro 4: How do they compare?

Microsoft took the tech world by storm with its October 2015 launch event, unveiling the expected Surface Pro 4 and the decidedly unexpected Surface Book.

Both have been getting good reviews - including from us - but how do these two Windows 10 hybrids compare to one another?

Let's take a closer look and see if we can't find out.

Related: Everything you need to know about the Microsoft Surface Pro 5

Surface Book

Surface Book vs Surface Pro 4: Design

Surface Book: Magnesium casing, 312.3 x 232.1 x 13 / 22.8mm, 1516g

Surface Pro 4: Magnesium casing, 292.1 x 201.4 x 8.4mm, 786g (1078g with Type Cover)

Ostensibly what we have here are two 2-in-1 Windows 10 devices, combining the best features of the tablet and laptop form factors. But beyond this superficial similarity the Surface Book and Surface Pro 4 represent two very different designs.

The Surface Pro 4 is a familiar super-sized tablet that forms a kind-of-laptop only by means of an optional keyboard-cover add-on.

The Surface Book, on the other hand, is a solid laptop first and foremost. It's just that you can also remove that display from its solid keyboard base to form a digital clipboard (aka an even bigger tablet).

Both feature a sharp, angular metallic (magnesium) design language, but the Surface Book has the addition of a distinctive snake-like hinge that unfurls and flattens as you open it out. Both are striking bits of kit in their own way.

However, the Surface Book is much chunkier than the Surface Pro 4. Even with the optional Type Cover added, the Pro 4 is almost 50% lighter.

Related: Microsoft Surface Book: 5 Features that will make you want one

Surface Pro 4

Surface Book vs Surface Pro 4: Display

Surface Book: 13.5-inch PixelSense display, 3000 x 2000 resolution

Surface Pro 4: 12.3-inch PixelTouch display, 2736 x 1824 resolution

The Surface Book has the bigger display of the two devices by 1.2-inches. However, it also has a slightly higher resolution of 3,000 x 2,000.

As a result of this, the two screens boast an identical pixel density of 267ppi. That's extremely sharp for a device of this form factor.

By way of a comparison, the 15-inch MacBook Pro Retina's screen - one of the first and most popular in this class of super-sharp portables - produces 220ppi.

Essentially, Microsoft has produced two of the crispest screens on the market.

When it comes to colour temperature, both displays get pretty close to the 6,500K ideal. What's interesting is that they come down either side of that figure.

The Surface Pro 4 scored a slightly warm 6,946K, while the Surface Book came in with an ever so slightly cool - but generally pretty great - 6,377K.

As for colour accuracy, the Surface Pro 4 is technically inferior again, with a Delta E score of 0.67 next to the Surface Book's 0.19. However, any score below 1 is pretty much imperceptible to the human eye, so both are great in this respect.

The two devices are about equal on the sRGB spectrum - 96.2 percent for the Surface Pro 4, and 94.3 percent for the Surface Book.

They're also similarly average when it comes to their Adobe RGB scores - 68.3 percent for the Surface Pro 4 and 67.6 percent for the Surface Book. Given that both should be appealing to designers with their well-integrated Surface Pen peripherals, that's a bit of a disappointment.

Surface GPU

Surface Book vs Surface Pro 4: Power

Surface Book: 6th gen Intel i5 / i7 (with NVIDIA GeForce GPU), 8GB / 16GB RAM

Surface Pro 4: 6th gen Intel m3 / i5 / i7 CPU, 4GB / 8GB / 16GB RAM

Both Surface hybrids are powered by a choice of sixth generation Intel processors, though the Surface Pro 4 starts at a lowlier m3 option.

At the other end of the scale, the Surface Book pairs its top i7 CPU with a custom discrete Nvidia GeForce GPU that's been tweaked and optimised by the Xbox team. The Pro simply doesn't have this luxury.

Our 3DMark FireStrike benchmark tests suggest that, when docked, the top-specced Surface Book is more than twice as fast as the equivalent Surface Pro 4 - a clear result of that bespoke GeForce GPU.

Both devices come with a choice of 8GB or 16GB of RAM, but the smaller device also features an entry-level 4GB option. Basically, there's plenty of power on tap for both hybrid devices, but the Surface Book has the edge.

Buy Now: Surface Book at Amazon.com from $1,229

Best Deals for Microsoft Surface Book

  • ebay

Surface Pro 4

Surface Book vs Surface Pro 4: Input

Surface Book: Integrated keyboard, Surface Pen

Surface Pro 4: Optional Touch / Type Cover, Surface Pen

The way these two devices approach the matter of keyboards is arguably their defining difference.

As mentioned, the Surface Pro 4's keyboard is optional, and the device doesn't ship with one as standard. You have a choice of a larger Type Cover keyboard or a lighter Touch Cover.

The Type Cover is the one that Microsoft was keen to show off at its launch event, and it's been much improved over previous versions. The keys have been better spaced out than before, and they have a new butterfly scissor mechanism that offers a more solid feel, rather like the new MacBook.

Also, the Type Cover's touchpad has been much improved. It's bigger, and it's now covered by glass for a smoother experience.

Meanwhile the Surface Book comes with a more traditional keyboard as standard. We say traditional, but the magnetised connection and 'snake' hinge system is anything but standard, effectively making this hybrid act like a proper laptop.

Interestingly, this keyboard also houses the aforementioned Nvidia GPU in the top specification, as well as a bunch of batteries. It's much more than just an accessory.

These are both Surface devices, which means that they both come with the latest Surface Pen as standard.

This latest Microsoft stylus boasts 1,024 levels of pressure sensitivity for its fine (and interchangeable) tip, while the opposite end acts as an eraser. This eraser also doubles as a shortcut to Microsoft's Cortana personal assistant.

Buy Now: Surface Pro 4 at Amazon.com from $678

Best Deals for Microsoft Surface Pro 4

  • amazon
  • ebay

Surface Book ports

Surface Book vs Surface Pro 4: Connectivity

Surface Book: 2 x USB 3.0, SD slot, 3.5mm headphone port, Mini DisplayPort

Surface Pro 4: 1 x USB 3.0, microSD slot, 3.5mm headphone port, Mini DisplayPort

These are two well-connected devices for their size, but the larger Surface Book is understandably the better connected of the two.

It's got two full-sized USB 3.0 ports to the Surface Pro 4's one, while it also has the benefit of a full-sized SD card slot to the Surface Pro 4's microSD.

Both have Mini DisplayPort connections too, as well as the usual array of Wi-Fi and Bluetooth 4.0 options.

Surface

Surface Book vs Surface Pro 4: Storage

Surface Book: 128GB / 256GB / 512GB / 1TB SSD

Surface Pro 4: 128GB / 256GB / 512GB / 1TB SSD

Rather impressively, both Surface devices have identical storage options - and neither is found wanting.

These start from 128GB as the bare minimum and go right up to 1TB solid state drives. Plenty of storage whatever you choose.

Surface Book vs Surface Pro 4: Price

Surface Book: £1,299 - £2,249

Surface Pro 4: £749 - £1,799

Both devices offer a wide range of spec options, resulting in a difference of around £1,000 between the entry and top models of each.

However, while the Surface Pro 4 offers something for a range of budgets, the Surface Book is either expensive or really expensive.

It starts for a not inconsiderable £1,299, and that's for the i5 model with no dedicated GPU - one of the big selling points for this machine. If you want the GeForce GPU (which you do), then pricing starts from £1,599. The top model, meanwhile, costs an eye-watering £2,249.

Buy Now: Surface Book at Amazon.com from $1,229

Best Deals for Microsoft Surface Book

  • ebay

While it's true that the Surface Pro 4 has its own hamstrung entry-level model in the £749 Intel Core m3 tier, we can see how this would still be a genuinely useful and appealing option for many. Even then, £100 extra will get you a 'proper' i5 CPU.

Of course, the top Surface Pro 4 costs a stiff £1,799, and you need to factor in the cost of a Type Cover on top of the base cost, but it generally seems like better value than the Surface Book.

Buy Now: Surface Pro 4 at Amazon.com from $678

Best Deals for Microsoft Surface Pro 4

  • amazon
  • ebay

SurfaceBookvsSurfaceFINAL

Verdict

At first glance, it was tempting to speculate that Microsoft had trodden on its own toes with the launch of the Surface Book alongside the Surface Pro 4. But really, the two devices fill two subtly different needs.

The Surface Pro 4 is the latest refinement of a form factor Microsoft has come to define - a tablet with the power of a laptop, which can be lugged around like an iPad, but which is capable of far greater productivity when the need arises.

However, the Surface range has never been more than adequate as a laptop. It's never been something you could conceivably (or at least comfortably) use as a daily, all-day work device. The Surface Book is just that, with its ingenious full keyboard design, slightly larger display, and discrete GPU option.

Still, there's one stand-out factor that swings things in the Surface Pro 4's favour overall - price. The Surface Book costs an awful lot of money, particularly when it comes to securing that model with the difference-making dedicated GPU. Put simply, you can get a competitive laptop for an awful lot less.

Conversely, the Surface Pro 4 is a compelling package with a more reasonable range of price points. There's no other hybrid that offers quite the same quality experience at this price, let alone for less money.

Related: Microsoft Surface Pro 4 review

Charlie Briggs

October 9, 2015, 7:38 pm

"Meanwhile the Surface Pro comes with a more traditional keyboard as standard. We say traditional, but the magnetised connection and 'snake' hinge system is anything but standard, effectively making this hybrid act like a proper laptop."

Surface Book here rather than Pro.

Matthias12

October 10, 2015, 4:54 am

"However, the Surface range has never been more than adequate as a laptop. It's never been something you could conceivably use as a daily, all-day work device." I hear this a lot! Makes me wonder what the average Joe Doe does at work that makes the Surface insufficient. I am a biophysics prof in medicine and do everything from matlab to adobe premiere or heavy duty microscopy software from Zeiss for example, or solid works, driving also a WXGA monitor and my surface pro 3 does just fine :). It's all I ever use...

toboev

October 10, 2015, 12:25 pm

So it's not just me who finds their product names befuddling! I await with eager anticipation the launch of a 'Pro' version of the Surface Book...

Gordon McNair

October 10, 2015, 3:53 pm

I do all the advertising for our tutoring center running the full Adobe CC on the i5 SP3. I often have multiple Adobe apps open as well as internet and email. I have never felt like the SP3 was holding me back. IMHO, SP3 outperforms half the business class desktops and laptops for the same price.

John

October 10, 2015, 4:23 pm

1.5kg for a 12.5" machine is pretty heavy these days.

John

October 10, 2015, 4:24 pm

XPS13 over either.

Abdulrehman yousef

October 21, 2015, 3:01 pm

will surface book have a type cover like the surface pro 4 please tell me thank you

Guest

December 13, 2015, 11:59 am

comment about XPS13 found in http://www.chipchick.com/2015/...
"(...) check your version, but mine does not respond well to stylus. For example you cannot write anything with stylus. It works with finger writing, but not stylus."

LeeTronix

March 1, 2016, 11:44 pm

I prefer the SP4 I think its a really tidy package and more versatile IMO. I have seen and used the SB and first thing is I thought it looked dull when I saw and used it. The colour of the SB seems painfully boring and when you open it up and see the same tone colour of the keys and mat steel type feel look its not pretty.

I also found the SB book screen to be really awkward and over light on the touch. There is no way you can use this as a touch screen while its docked to the board in laptop mode because of the screen wobble. Even when I got into a focused typing frenzy I noticed the screen wobbling around more than it should and it irrupted my flow and irritated me no end. I did not like the way it dispatches or undocks the screen from the base just not a pleasant experience and it also keeps crashing often when waiting for the electronic beep to release...annoying...

I think for the SB is I wouldn't buy one period. And the top of the range cost should be the entry level price I am not kidding, yes I know it sounds mad but its just not a good device for its money.

The SP4 wins hands down for me in every way. I can't fault it and its so easy and solid when used as laptop or tablet. Screen is excellent and just an all round good device. I would say if you have an SP3 I think its worth the upgrade for sure but don't rule out your SP3 either.

Arel

March 2, 2016, 8:46 am

Same here (he says, typing away at his docked SP3). Office apps run up fine, databases run fine, code compiles quickly enough. I'm curious as to what uses the reviewer has found an SP3/4 only adequate for?

Joseph Oliveira

May 31, 2016, 1:56 pm

I suspect you need a different stylus than the one you're using.

comments powered by Disqus