Home » Opinions » Samsung Galaxy S4 vs Note 2

Samsung Galaxy S4 vs Note 2

by | Go to comments

Share:
Note 2 vs S4
Note 2 vs S4

The Galaxy series has taken over Android in many people’s eyes. But there’s more to the series than just the Galaxy S flagships.

The Galaxy Note 2 is one of the most interesting Android phones out there thanks to its clever stylus, but how does it compare to the Galaxy S4? Let’s find out.

Samsung Galaxy S4 vs Note 2 – Design

Galaxy S4 – Plastic rear, Gorilla Glass 3 front, 7.9mm thick, 130g
Galaxy Note 2 – Plastic rear, toughened glass, 9.4mm thick, 183g

The Note 2 and Galaxy S4 use the staple Galaxy-series design template. That means a removable plastic rear that flexes a good deal when taken off the back. It’s super-thin.

This style has earned the phones a lot of criticism, but drop tests show that it’s not a bad kind of construction – the plastic soaks up impact much better than metal, which tends to transfer more of the force to the highly-smashable screen. Note vs S4 1
Galaxy S4 rear

Both phones use toughened glass for their display fronts but – predictably – the Galaxy S4’s is a little more advanced. The S4 uses third-generation Gorilla Glass while the Note 2 uses an unspecified toughened glass layer – some say it is second-generation Gorilla Glass.

Gorilla Glass is great at avoiding scratches from things like keys and coins, largely removing the need for a screen protector unless you really want to keep your phone pristine in order to sell it on down the line.

There are also clear advancements in its body shape. The Note 2 is significantly chunkier than the S4, a full 1.5mm thicker. It’s also a whopping 55g heavier.
 Note vs S4 3
Note 2

Some of this is down to Samsung getting to grips with how to make its phones slimmer, but there’s also the stylus to consider. The Note 2 has a cubby hole to store its digitiser stylus down the bottom – and this is the top reason why the Note 2 isn’t super-slim.

Versus

Samsung Galaxy S4 vs Note 2 – Screen

Galaxy S4 – 5-inch 1080p Super AMOLED, 441 ppi
Galaxy Note 2 – 5.5-inch 1,280 x 720 Super AMOLED, 267 ppi

Although the Note 2’s screen is significantly larger than the S4’s – 0.5 inches extra may not sound like a lot, but it pushes the Note 2 into another size bracket – its screen resolution is significantly lower.

The Galaxy S4 has double the number of pixels, an eye-opening 2,000,000-plus against the Note 2’s 900,000-odd. However, the Note 2 remains pretty sharp because, unlike the Galaxy S4, it doesn’t use a PenTile array display.

OLED screens like those of the Galaxy series of phones often use a PenTile array, which is an uneven sub-pixel arrangement that reduces sharpness. It was pretty noticeable in the Galaxy S3, but in the S4 the 1080p brings high enough pixel density for the problem to fade. As it doesn’t use a PenTile display, the Note 2’s 267ppi display looks fairly sharp too.

Let’s not overstate things, though – the Galaxy S4 is still in another class. Contrast and top brightness are superior. The Galaxy S4 has a truly zingy, impressive screen.
Note vs S4 6

Both phones also give you some customisation of the screen’s settings. Super AMOLED displays tend to oversaturate colours, but both phones have a menu that lets you set the screen to ‘neutral’ colouring for a cooler, more relaxed look.
 
Versus 4

Samsung Galaxy S4 vs Note 2 – Stylus

Galaxy S4 – No included stylus, capacitive stylus support only, ‘finger stylus’ emulation via AirView
Galaxy Note 2 – Digitiser stylus included, 1,024 pressure levels

The Galaxy Note 2‘s key selling point is its digitiser. This is a special screen layer that lets the phone interact with a special stylus that slots into the phone’s bottom edge.

The digitiser is made by Wacom, which produces ‘industry standard’ graphics tablets like the Wacom Intuos 5. It allows for 1,024 pressure sensitivity levels – enabling some pretty convincing drawing apps. The stylus rib is made of rubbery material, which gives a pretty natural-feeling response on the display’s glass too.
Note vs S4 5
Some people think the stylus is a bit of a gimmick, but in use it’s great – and the preinstalled S-Note is a great stylus-optimised app that lets you takes notes, make presentations and all sorts.

The Samsung Galaxy S4 does not have a digitiser layer. You can use a stylus, but it’ll have to be the standard capacitive kind, which simply responds in the same manner as your finger. There’s no pressure sensitivity, and no sensing of the stylus when it’s hovering above the screen.

There is another bit of tech that impersonates this, though. AirView makes the phone respond to your finger when it hovers above the screen, using super-cranked screen sensitivity.

Versus 2

Samsung Galaxy S4 vs Note 2 - Software

Galaxy S4 – Android 4.2 with TouchWiz
Galaxy Note 2 – Android 4.1 with TouchWiz

The two phones use Samsung’s long-standing TouchWiz interface, laid on top of the Android operating system. The Galaxy S4 is a generation ahead of the Note 2, and it has several extra bits of functionality.

One of the most significant – and one that can’t simply be added with an update – is IR blaster functionality. This lets you control your TV with the Galaxy S4, using the WatchOn app. AirView is another feature that may come to the Note 2. For more on these, read our round-up of the best new TouchWiz features.

Note vs S4
The S4's TouchWiz

Other features, such as Smart Scroll, S Translator and Smart Pause, are likely to come to the Note 2 with a software update.

The two versions of TouchWiz look more-or-less identical too – the Samsung Android style has remained fairly consistent over the last few years.

Software features that the Note 2 can brag about relate to its stylus. The Note 2 lets you scrawl over the screen wherever you are and save your notes as images for retrieval later on – and the S-Note drawing/note-taking app has been thoroughly optimised for the pen. Note vs S4 7
Note 2 TouchWiz

At present, the Galaxy S4 uses a slightly more up-to-date version of the Android OS, with 4.2 Jelly Bean rather than 4.1.2 Jelly Bean. It’s not a huge difference.

Versus

Samsung Galaxy S4 vs Note 2 – Power

Galaxy S4 – Quad-core Snapdragon 600 1.9GHz, 2GB RAM
Galaxy Note 2 – Quad-core Exynos 4412 1.6GHz, 2GB RAM

The Galaxy Note 2 was one of the first phones to ship with 2GB of RAM, setting the standard for this year’s 2GB RAM phones, including the Galaxy S4.

The CPU is another matter, however. Both phones use quad-core CPUs, but there’s a generation gap between the processors.

Samsung’s Galaxy Note 2 uses the same processor as the Galaxy S3, a quad-core Exynos 4412 chip. It’s clocked at 1.6GHz.

The Galaxy S4 has a Snapdragon 600 chipset clocked at 1.9GHz. It doesn’t sound like a huge difference, but the two have completely different architecture types. The Snapdragon 600 uses a 28nm process, while the Note 2’s Exynos 4412 is stuck with ‘old’ 32nm. Increased miniaturisation means higher efficiency, more power.

AnTuTu benchmark tests tell the story in an empirical way. The Note 2 scores around 18,000 points, the Galaxy S4 around 25,000.

Rather than just a more advanced CPU, the Galaxy S4 also has a snazzier GPU. The Galaxy Note 2 uses the Mali-400, the Galaxy S4 the Adreno 320.

The difference between the two isn’t massive, but the Adreno is a little more powerful.

As the phones both have 2GB of RAM, the difference in performance is not huge, but the Galaxy S4 is clearly the more powerful phone.

Versus 4

Samsung Galaxy S4 vs Note 2 – Camera

Galaxy S4 – 13-megapixel, LED flash, 2-megapixel front camera, f/2.2
Galaxy Note 2 – 8-megapixel, LED flash, 1.9-megapixel front camera, f/2.6

The cameras of these phones demonstrate yet another generational shift. The Note 2 has an 8-megapixel sensor, the Galaxy S4 a higher-resolution 13-megapixel sensor.

It’s not quite as big an upgrade as it may sound, though, as the size of the sensor hasn’t really increased. Samsung has simply crammed more sensor pixels into the same space.
 Note vs S4 2

Each sensor pixel in the Galaxy S4 is 1.12 microns in size, while the Note 2’s are a little larger at 1.3 microns. Having tiny sensor pixels is bad for low-light performance but, as with just about every phone, low-light performance is pretty sketchy in both.

The higher resolution of the Galaxy S4 makes shots taken in good lighting more detailed than those of the Note 2.

Both cameras are a delight to use, though, with good macro skills and quick focusing.

The Galaxy S4 is more advanced in other respects too. It has an f/2.2 lens while the Note 2 uses a slower f/2.6 lens. A slower lens means the camera needs to use longer exposure times, and reduces the depth of field effects a camera can produce. This is where the background appears out of focus, while the foreground is pin-sharp.

Versus

Verdict

In most respects, the Samsung Galaxy S4 is clearly a generation ahead of the Note 2. A faster processor, more advanced screen, better camera and newer software age the Note. However, none of the new features are total deal-breakers, and the digitiser of the Note 2 is still a huge draw.

Go to comments
comments powered by Disqus