Home / Opinions / Microsoft Surface Pro 4 vs Dell XPS 12: How do they compare?

Microsoft Surface Pro 4 vs Dell XPS 12

by

Surface Pro 4

There's two new Widndows 10 hybirds vying for your attention. But do you go Surface Pro 4 or Dell XPS 12? Let's take a look.

Within the space of a couple of days, two stellar 2-in-1 Windows 10 tablet hybrids have been announced in the Microsoft Surface Pro 4 and the Dell XPS 12.

So which impresses more based on early impressions?

Both promise to provide the best 2-in-1 experience out there, offering all the casual convenience of a tablet with the productivity of a laptop.

Here's what the new Surface Pro and XPS 12 have to offer.

Related: Everything you need to know about the Microsoft Surface Pro 5

Dell wins on sharpness (sort of)

Both of these hybrid devices have sharp 12-inch displays. In fact, the 12.5-inch Dell XPS 12 is ever so slightly larger than the 12.3-inch Microsoft Surface Pro 4, but not significantly so.

Perhaps more significant will be the relative sharpness of the Dell XPS 12's display - or rather, one of them. While the Surface Pro 4 screen is a fixed 2736 x 1824 - offering an impressive 5 million pixels - the Dell XPS 12 comes with an optional 3840 x 2160 UltraSharp display, which has 8 million pixels.

That makes it the first 4K display to be found in a 2-in-1 device.

The other Dell display option is a decidedly less impressive 1920 x 1080 Full HD number, so Microsoft wins points for consistency here.

XS12

XPS design more laptopy

While these are 2-in-1 hybrid devices, to a large extent they live and die by how well they perform as a productivity tool - the laptop part of the equation.

Initial impressions suggest that the Dell XPS 12 is the more laptop-like of the two, with a solid, traditionally aligned, magnetically attached keyboard.

Microsoft has made improvements to the (still optional) Touch Cover's keyboard feel for the Surface Pro 4, however. It has better-spaced keys, which also benefit from a new butterfly scissor mechanism (like the latest MacBook), and it also gets a vastly improved glass trackpad.

XS12

Surface design more portable

Of course, the Dell's more laptop-like design also makes it quite a bit bulkier and less portable than the Surface Pro 4.

While the total Dell package weighs in at a relatively lardy 1270g, the Microsoft Surface Pro 4 comes in at just 1078g with the Type Cover included.

Even here, in what is ostensibly the same 2-in-1 category, then, you'll see that there are some significantly different approaches to the format.

Related: Best laptops 2015

Surface Pro 4

Active Pen vs Surface Pen

This slight difference in approach that we mentioned above extends to the implementation of each device's stylus. While the Dell Active Pen is an optional extra, every Surface Pro 4 comes with a Surface Pen bundled in.

The new Microsoft stylus is much improved over the previous iterations, with 1024 levels of pressure sensitivity, a handy eraser (which doubles as a Cortana prompt), and the ability to stick to the side of the Surface when not in use through magnetisation.

Surface Pro 4

Surface better connected

The Surface Pro 4 is arguably the better-connected device of the two, with a full-sized USB 3.0 port, a Mini DisplayPort, and a microSD card reader joining the usual Bluetooth 4.1 and 802.11ac Wi-Fi options.

The Dell XPS 12, meanwhile, packs just two Thunderbolt 3 ports (utilising the new USB Type-C reversible connection standard) and a microSD slot besides 802.11ac Wi-Fi and Bluetooth 4.1.

It's a set-up that's perhaps more future-proof than the Surface Pro 4's, but in the here and now it looks less flexible that Microsoft's latest.

Related: Surface Book: 5 features that will make you want one

Surface 4

Similar Performance and storage

Both devices run on the latest 6th generation Intel CPUs with Intel Iris 515 GPUs, so it should be fairly even in performance terms.

While the Dell appears to come with 8GB of RAM as standard, the Surface Pro 4 has a choice of 4GB, 8GB, and 16GB.

Both the Dell XPS 12 and the Microsoft Surface Pro 4 have a choice of 128GB and 256GB SSD storage, but the Surface also has a 512GB option. Those looking for maximum physical storage might favour the Microsoft machine.

Early Verdict

Even at this early stage, it's easy to see that these will be the two leading 2-in-1 devices for the foreseeable future, and two of the best Windows 10 devices full-stop.

Yet there are interesting differences between the two, with the Dell looking to be the better bet for those seeking a more faithful laptop experience.

The Surface Pro 4, meanwhile, looks to be the best version of a truly genre-defining range.

We can't wait to put them both through their paces to see which is the best device in day to day life.

Related: Microsoft Surface Pro 4 review

Lucas R.

October 9, 2015, 3:14 pm

Actually the Surface Pro 4's screen is bigger. If you do the math the surface area of the Surface Pro calculates to 450.49 cm^2 and the area of the XPS is 430.745 cm^2.

aeonturnip

October 12, 2015, 11:39 am

"Widndows 10 hybirds" - awesome typo sequence.

Augie

November 21, 2016, 7:07 am

What are you smoking? Are you equating the footprint of both items (the surface area of the actual unit)? Or the surface area of the screen. 12.9in at 16:9 aspect ratio is larger than 12.5in at 16:9 aspect ratio. It's literally that simple. Screens are measured diagonally.

Also, for what it's worth, the Dell's screen at 4k resolution blows the surface out of the water. The writer here is being biased towards advertised tech.

You know why the Surface is so expensive? Advertising.
The dell trounces the surface. And right now that unit is $400 off, at $899. Again, because you don't see DELL billboards all over the place. They're not marking things up due to egregious ad spend.

The Surface has a larger footprint than the Dell because of it's ugly BEZELS. Talk about poor design. What iteration are they on, now?

Lucas R.

December 9, 2016, 7:35 pm

The aspect ratio of the surface pro is 3:2 vs. 16:9 of the DELL.
Therefore the display of the Surface Pro 4 actually is bigger.

comments powered by Disqus