Home » Opinions » Nexus 4 and Galaxy Note 2: Living with a big screen phone

Nexus 4 and Galaxy Note 2: Living with a big screen phone

Gordon Kelly by

Nexus 4 and Galaxy Note 2: Living with a big screen phone

meBack in January I argued it is time to embrace big screen phones and it drew a lot of response. The motivation came from being a long term iPhone user who has owned every model, but didn’t feel the urge to purchase the fractionally larger iPhone 5. It seems I am not alone in this, as iPhone 5 sales are reportedly not meeting expectations. The next step was logical: live with some large screen phones and report back about how I got on. That time is now.

Lesson 1: Get a Grip

I picked two handsets for the test period, spending a week with each. The first was Samsung’s 5.5-inch Galaxy Note 2, the second Google’s 4.7-inch Nexus 4.

In hindsight I got the order wrong. Wanting to jump in head first with what is currently the largest screen on any smartphone was bold, but foolish. Day one saw me running late for a meeting and rushing down the street, motorcycle helmet in one hand, phone in the other, frantically trying to send an apologetic text message. The experience had me lamenting the absence of my iPhone 4S. But as is so common in early relationships the problem proved to be: ‘it’s not you, it’s me’.

Note 2 hand

It turns out what moving to a big screen phone requires is learning new muscle memory. It isn’t about weight (the iPhone 4S is quite a porker in this regard), but grip. Wider screens result in a wider grip and this reduces the reach of your fingers, resulting in the much repeated ‘but you can’t use them one-handed’ speech.

This is true… at first. With time you realise a big screen phone doesn’t sit dormant in your palm while your fingers move, it moves up and down your palm to allow your fingers to reach things. It’s awkward to start with (and far more so on the Note 2 than the Nexus 4) but, like forming chords on the guitar, quickly becomes second nature.

Lesson 2: Typing Nirvana

Much is made of the fact big screen phones can’t be used for typing one-handed, but in practice I found this simply wasn’t true. Most simply, apps are available that will shrink a keyboard and lock it to the left or right side of the keyboard, depending on whether you are left or right handed. This will accommodate even the smallest hands.

For long-term iPhone users the other real game changer is keyboards like Swiftkey and its ‘Flow’ system, which simply requires users to swipe between letters and to the spacebar without ever leaving the screen. This lets you keep a grip on the phone and simultaneously type with ease. Android 4.2 introduced a similar system, but until it incorporates the spacebar and better customisation to your writing style (Swiftkey has the option to scan your emails and social media to learn your vocabulary and abbreviations) it will lag behind.

Needless to say when typing two handed, via Swiftkey or not, these larger screen sizes also make things easier than their smaller screen equivalents while being less unwieldy than a tablet.

Lesson 3: Promising Productivity

With the biggest queries addressed the upsides of a big phone came to the forefront. Most notably - you can get more done, more quickly. Muscle memory can work against you with an iPhone too and it is amazing just how accustomed you become to continually moving things around to complete each task.

The iPhone's 3.5-inch screen means writing emails or instant messages requires regular scrolling to check the original message, browsing requires continuous zooming and swiping around a page and consistently turning to landscape mode and apps are more cramped. These aren’t eliminated with a big screen phone but you do them far less, simply because you can see more at any one time. Returning to an iPhone felt exhausting by comparison, it was like returning to work on a desktop PC with a 14-inch monitor.

nexus4

Lesson 4: Better Battery Life

This is far from universal, but the trend on phones is the bigger the screen the better the battery life. This for the simple reason that the chipset, even if more powerful, only increases fractionally in size while there is a lot more room for a much bigger battery that more-than offsets the larger screen. For example, the Note 2’s famously capacious 3100mAh battery saw it last a full day even when used intensively (including hours of GPS navigation and tethering) and up to two days with moderate usage.

The 2100mAh battery in the Nexus 4 also got me through a day and we’ve previously found this true with the 2100mAh sporting Galaxy S3 (though there are some conflicting reports) and the HTC One X(plus).

The iPhone 4S on the other hand is limited to a 1430mAh battery and the iPhone 5 could only make space for this to be increased by 10mAh to 1440mAh which shows the tight squeeze. Contrast this with talk that a 5-inch Samsung Galaxy S4 will fit a Note 2-matching 3100mAh battery. Of course processor optimisation, operating system efficiency, users’ individual settings and much more play a huge role, but that you can fit physically larger batteries into big screen phones remains a simple reality. Needless to say many large screen phones also have replaceable batteries, though not the Nexus 4.

sizes

Lesson 5: Phablet Means Less Tablet

As an iPad user I found my usage of the tablet fell through the floor when using a large phone. At 3.5 inches the iPhone was always dumped once I got home, but a bigger screen phone remains a pleasurable way to consume content back in your abode and I enjoyed not having to hop between two devices. I’m sure tablet aficionados won’t be dumping their iPads in droves, but intrinsically you rely on them less and don’t always feel the need to take them everywhere with you.

Discussing architect plans with a builder, for instance, was easy on the Note 2 and amusingly, as an iPhone owner, he wanted one by the end of the conversation.

Video is the other big benefit as I quickly found myself taking films and episodes of TV with me for longer journeys and again leaving the tablet on the coffee table.

Lesson 6: Size is Addictive

After a week using the Nexus 4 its 4.7-inch screen felt small. This would have seemed ludicrous to me a few weeks back, but talking with owners of other 4.7-inch handsets I found they could relate. By contrast having lived for so long with a 3.5-inch display I had stopped asking the question... ironically right up until the launch of the iPhone 5 which made me sit up and declare “that’s not big enough”.

stats

Interestingly most of 2013’s flagship smartphones will sport five inch screens - the number isn’t picked out at random, manufacturers have done their research. So too has IHS Suppli, which says handsets with 5in screens or more will see shipments double from 25.6m to 60.4m in 2013 making it by far the fastest growing segment. By 2016 it predicts sales of over 140m, though with Apple shipping 130m iPhones alone in 2012 it shows smaller phones continue to have massive appeal and significantly, outside of Apple, lower retail prices.

Verdict: Size Matters

It must be stressed this is my personal opinion and yours may differ strongly, but what has struck me since living with (as opposed to reviewing) a big screen phone is I’m loathe to return to my iPhone and it is a size issue. The iPhone 5 made me realise I didn't want to step up just 0.5 inches and if all Apple delivers is an iPhone 5S in July/August it will be 2014 before something larger comes along.

I’ve got the size bug and right now that means Apple can’t cater for me, whatever I think of iOS. With curious iPhone 4 and 4S customers either out of or coming towards the end of their contracts that’s a dangerous place for Apple to be in. Android, Windows Phone and BlackBerry users all now have handset options with displays in excess of Apple’s four inches and if Apple is loathe to risk cannibalising its iPad mini sales then paralysis could be the biggest threat of all.

Despite all this I must admit the iPhone remains the easiest phone to use one handed, even if the margins were smaller than I expected. What I will say though is that alone is no longer enough to determine what my next handset will be. Ultimately if you have been considering taking on more inches I urge you to do so. As Apple once said, 'It's Resolutionary'.

Note: many thanks to Three for the loan of both handsets

Go to comments

meerkat82

February 18, 2013, 1:09 pm

I am currently considering the Sony Xperia Z with a 5" screen (why, oh why, do we use the antiquated "imperial" system to measure something so high tech in the 21st century). But, I am also considering their rumoured 6.44" (urgh) offering as well. So long as I can get it in a pocket, the bigger the better. If I have to carry it in a bag maybe a smartwatch will allow me to communicate with the device up until I need to remove it and handle it. Now I can justifiably carry around my document, music, photo and movie collection (too bad the memory maxes out at 48 GB). If I need to show anyone anything or review it myself, I have it with me, displayed on a screen as large as printed photo

toboev

February 18, 2013, 4:32 pm

I've never understood the argument for "not cannibalising your own market". Who do these managements prefer would cannibalise their market - themselves, or the other company? That is the choice. Ask the guys at Kodak whether the second option is any good.

adam222green

February 18, 2013, 7:07 pm

The most important observation I would underscore in this hands-on assessment is that talking about display size is just a discussion, but once you see someone using a larger display smartphone, once you see the practical advantage in real life, you can make an informed decision based on your own criteria. That took me from an iPhone to a Nexus. It's not Google vs Apple (at least in my choices) so if/when Apples brings the iPhone 6, that could well be the next step for me. I think somewhere around a 5 inch display will suit me. Any time I need something larger, but not the Mac, I pick up a tablet. Any time I can do anything on the tablet, I never "want" to use the phone. I'd never read a book on the Nexus 4 or the MacBook Pro Retina, it's just awkward. I read on the Nexus 10 – it's very comfortable in the hands and to the eyes.
I think technology has settled on about 5 inch phones, 10 or 12 inch tablets and 15 or 17 inch laptops.
As the author notes, when my kids see an "old" 22 inch monitor on my PC, they say "wow, that's really tiny" (because they're accustomed to a 27 inch iMac or my ("ancient") 30 inch Cinema. That's state of the art for me – Apple should bring out another 30 inch Cinema in this new iMac svelteness. But I digress …

adam222green

February 18, 2013, 7:33 pm

After retiring from a career spanning three decades (and two centuries) in Silicon Valley, in charge of products with these "boundary effects" and "interference" and trying to make these sorts of decisions, I'm sure there's no answer.

Look at brands from Porsche to Polaroid, you can study the history of good decisions that went wrong and bad decisions that went on to unparalleled success.

Apple might be the brand that defines the art of brands for the 20th century (and the 21st century to date) but along with its strength, there have been equally great weaknesses. Perhaps the easiest to observe is the one-button mouse, though it doesn't explain cannibalism, it illustrates how even the most creative genius can become stubborned resistant to adapting or risking the "weakness" of offering seemingly overlapping products.

So long as there are fiefdoms in tech companies, there will be this peculiar insistance upon clearly separated product boundaries. At least Apple has started to blur its product boundaries -- a phone as powerful as a tablet, a thin "ultra book" laptop that's a good desktop replacement. The blur makes just as much sense to me as having sharply delineated products that deliberately omit features and functionality to make way for adjacent products.

If anything, it's fear of blurring ones own product boundaries that creates the product line gaps that allow wedge products to find purchase in the market.

Gordon Kelly

February 18, 2013, 9:49 pm

You're spot on. What I was determined to do was not make this about Android vs iOS, it is simply about the physical size of big screen phones and how practica or impractical they are when truly living with them. If Apple makes a bigger iPhone it could well take me back to iPhones, but it really should give me the option.

I found moving to a big screen phone was such a strong experience I wouldn't want to go back. 5 inches does seem to be the right threshold.

Gordon Kelly

February 18, 2013, 9:50 pm

Very true. In fairness there are risks both ways.

Gordon Kelly

February 18, 2013, 9:52 pm

In defence of Apple it was brave enough to cannibalise much of iTunes with iCloud (as it removed the need for iTunes to backup/setup an iPhone) and (with the likes of Spotify) ignore it completely if you wish.

But yes, in general these boundaries can be as harmful as they are useful. Especially as devices become powerful enough to overlap and do so many jobs well.

Gordon Kelly

February 18, 2013, 9:54 pm

I think this is where smartwatches come in. Pulling our phones out for every buzz (when 9/10 are unimportant) is already an infuriating reflex smartwatches can ease, but equally this becomes key with large (5in+ handsets where one handed use can be restrictive). It's a combination which certainly has strong appeal for me.

Orhan Toker

February 19, 2013, 9:14 am

Poor Gordon,

Do you want me to send you an holder to attach yor Note II to motorcyle?

profile21

February 19, 2013, 7:31 pm

With regards to large mobile products like the Galaxy Note 2 I'm less concerned about not being able to use it one handed than where I store it. It's probably ok during winter as it can go into an inside pocket of a jacket but where are you going to put the thing in the summer?

Jon Kimball

February 19, 2013, 10:33 pm

Spot on. I moved from original iphone to iphone 4 (which I lost...) to a galaxy SIIx. The iphone 5 screen just wasn't big enough. The galaxy 4.5" screen is fantastic. Two words: readable powerpoint slides.
Yes, you do lose one handed operation, but the the iphone is not one handed anyway - as you noted you frequently have to pinch, zoom, scroll, swipe to do things and that usually involved two hands. I think overall one can do more on a large screen one handed than on an iphone simply because you don't need to squeeze into 3.5".
When I see someone tippy tapping away on those little screens I just sigh. I am never going back: 4.5" is my new minimum.

imaginarynumber

February 24, 2013, 3:08 pm

Seen it all before though...

Welcome to 2007, the iPhone hasn't been released yet but I have a 5" HTC Athena. It is finger friendly, stylus friendly, it even has a microsoft surface-esque screen cover that doubles up as a magnetic keyboard. With the exception of multi-touch and gyroscopes/accelerators it took apple at least 2 generations to match the hardware.

Roll forward half a decade and we seem to have forgotten that pre the iPhone there were some pretty amazing smartphones. The biggest difference is that those of us with smartphones were mocked for being nerds by people who find tying their shoe laces taxing

imaginarynumber

February 24, 2013, 3:20 pm

I agree re the smart watches. In it's filofax-type wallet my 2007 5" HTC would not fit in my trouser pockets. In the summer it lived in my rucksack. I did look at the available smartwatches such as the Fossil ones but they only worked properly with sony symbian phones. I did even consider BT "dumb client phones" but only one seems to have existed and had been discontinued. In the end I opted for a BT unit that allowed me to plug my own headphones in whilst being able to see incoming caller IDs and granted me basic media player controls.

Amjoco

March 13, 2013, 12:25 am

Clips on your belt or your belt can be run though a loop on the holster. It works for me because I'm older, if you are young and wanna be cool and not have to wear something on your hip, you better stick with a smaller phone! :) http://www.amazon.com/gp/produ...

comments powered by Disqus