Home / Opinions / Apple Pencil: How does it compare to the competition?

Apple Pencil: How does it compare to the competition?

by

Pencil feature 7

Is Apple’s answer to the stylus for the iPad Pro really revolutionary as it sounds? We compare it to the competition.

Alongside the iPad Pro, Apple's recently announced Pencil is now available to order.

Apple might be late to the stylus game (perhaps because Steve Jobs once famously derided the very concept) but then it’s rarely bothered with being the first to anything before. Rather, Apple tends to arrive a little late with a supremely polished or original take on a technology.

Sure enough, as Apple Pencil makes its debut, there are already plenty of third party iPad styluses on the market - many of which have established a considerable fan-base.

As is usually the case, some of Apple’s biggest rivals have also beaten it to market with their own distinct takes on the stylus.

We thought we’d take a look at the Apple Pencil alongside some of the best and most popular styluses around, and see how they compare feature-for-feature.

Apple Pencil

Price: £79/$99

Advantages: Compatibility, simplicity, sensitivity, easy charge

Disadvantages: Slippery design, limited iPad support, pricey

Apple took its time providing an iPad stylus, but the Apple Pencil will automatically become the best support iPad stylus by its mere existence. You can guarantee that third party app support will be unmatched, with heavy hitters like Microsoft and Adobe already confirmed as being onboard.

Then, of course, there’s Apple’s own pre-installed apps like Mail and Notes, which will have Apple Pencil support baked into iOS 9. It’s a considerable advantage.

It also looks like the Apple Pencil will have unmatched sensitivity, with its ability to sense multiple layers of pressure (though Apple doesn’t specify precisely how many), as well as the angle and orientation of the pen. It promises to provide an almost textural experience - hence the Pencil name - and you can also use your finger to affect the screen at the same time.

Related: 6 features that will make you want an iPad Pro

Pencil feature 5

Pairing and charging should be a doddle thanks to a built-in Lightning jack (which gives you 30 minutes of juice in just 15 seconds), and it’s completely button-less set-up is typically Apple.

However, it’s far from a hopeless situation for those pre-existing third party styluses, and that’s partly because Apple appears to have made some unusual missteps in the Apple Pencil’s design.

Apple’s stylus is a curiously large, plasticky device that doesn’t quite tally with the company’s typically classy, compact design work. Early hands-on reports have complained of it being slippery and unpleasant to hold.

It also seems likely to suffer for being completely cylindrical, which will invariably lead to it rolling off desks and artfully distressed coffee tables the world over. Tied in with that is a lack of storage facilities, there’s no magnetisation or even a clip with which to help stash the Pencil away.

The potential hiccups don’t end there. The Apple Pencil isn’t compatible with any other iPads other than the iPad Pro, and it’s by far the priciest stylus here at $99, which will probably translate to somewhere around the £80 or £90 mark.

Wacom Intuos Creative Stylus 2

Price: £64.99

Advantages: Fine pressure detection, palm rejection, rechargable battery

Disadvantages: Expensive, iPad Air 2 incompatibility

Wacom is one of the biggest names in stylus tech. It’s responsible for the likes of the Wacom Cintiq, a stand-alone stylus system used by many design professionals.

Wacom also channels that expertise into a small range of iPad styluses. The latest of these is the Intuos Creative Stylus 2.

As is Wacom’s stock in trade, the Intuous boast exemplary pressure sensitivity. It can detect a whopping 2048 degrees of pressure, reacting to the slightest variation in pressure. This is channelled through a fine 2.9mm writing tip, which is made from the same hard plastic material that goes into the Cintiq.

It also features built-in palm rejection, so you can rest your hand on the screen without messing things up. It’s a common feature among such high-end styluses, and the Apple Pencil appears to have it too.

Pencil feature 15

Unlike the Apple Pencil (and like most of its third party rivals), the Intuos Creative Stylus 2 has a hardware button.

One of the features we like about the Apple Pencil is its rechargeable battery, which is accessed through a neat built-in lightning jack. The Wacom also has a rechargeable battery, which can be filled using a packaged-in USB cable.

App compatibility isn’t exactly universal (a persistent problem with third party iPad styluses), but it does include the likes of Autodesk SketchBook, Adobe Photoshop Sketch, Wacom’s own Bamboo Paper, and a selection of other third party tools (Wacom mentions 18 in total).

One issue is that the Wacom effort doesn’t work with the iPad Air 2. This appears to be an issue faced by pretty much all styluses that use magnetic field tips, but it’s still annoying that Apple’s latest and greatest 10-incher is a no-go.

Surface Pen for Microsoft Surface Pro 3

Price: £45 alone, free with Surface Pro 3

Advantages: Dedicated OneNote buttons, Free with Surface

Disadvantages: Pressure sensitivity not what it used to be, standard batteries

Microsoft’s Windows hybrid remain peerless in its class, even a whole year on from its release. In fact, only its likely successor (tune in on October 6) is likely to surpass it for sheer all-round tablet-laptop mastery.

Indeed, it’s not difficult to see where Apple got the “inspiration” for the iPad Pro with Apple Pencil combo from. Microsoft can be forgiven a smug (if slightly worried) grin.

One of the key improvements to the latest model of the Surface Pro 3 has been an upgrade to its Surface Pen. Gone is the highly sensitive Wacom effort of previous models, and in its place comes a more general N-Trig effort.

It’s arguably more consistent in general usage than before, but the latest Surface with its Surface Pen has actually been scaled back in one way. The Surface Pro 3 N-Trig pen ‘only’ supports 256 levels of pressure sensitivity compared to the previous Wacom device’s 2048.

Related: Is the iPad Pro a MacBook or iPad Air rival?

Pencil feature 13

Of course, we’re comparing with Apple’s new solution here, and sadly we haven’t been given precise data on the Apple Pencil’s pressure sensitivity. It’s made some typically Apple-ish statements about precision and sensitivity, but nothing concrete.

Where the Apple Pencil does appear to trump the latest Surface Pen is in its tilt detection, which allows for the application of some subtle effects in drawing applications.

Of course, the Surface Pen appears to have a few advantages and extra features of its own.

The Surface Pen’s integration with the Surface Pro 3 is arguably its biggest plus. It comes with each and every Surface Pro 3 as part of the package, which inevitably means that it’s more deeply integrated with it than the Apple Pencil is with the iPad Pro.

As an example of that, the Surface Pen comes with a dedicated button for instant access to OneNote, Microsoft’s note-taking app, on the Surface Pro 3. With it, you can do things like jump straight to a new note from sleep.

Ultimately, Apple’s stylus may end up being the more sensitive, precise tool, but it will almost certainly lack the deep integration and all-round usefulness of the Surface Pro 3 with its bundled-in Surface Pen.

Samsung Galaxy Note 5 S Pen

Price: Free with Samsung Galaxy Note 5

Advantages: Compact, physically integrated into Note 5, deeply integrated into TouchWiz UI

Disadvantages: Not suited to prolonged or fine use

It’s not a tablet, but the Samsung Galaxy Note 5 deserves a mention in this feature because Samsung’s Note range with its S Pen stylus is one of the most popular stylus-driven platforms around. We shouldn't rule out that some form of S Pen technology crops up on the Galaxy View tablet that was teased by the Korean company earlier this month. For now, the Note 5’s S Pen is the latest iteration of this technology.

Samsung’s stylus is far more compact than any of the above rivals. It has to be, as it physically slots into the Note 5’s body - by far the neatest solution here. Having said that, there’s an issue here that means you can easily get the S Pen stuck and break the Note 5 by reinserting it the wrong way up.

Housing design issues aside, the S Pen’s compact size also means that it’s not as wieldy as the Apple Pencil and co. It’s intended for quickly scrawled notes rather than for composing your latest artistic masterpiece.

Related: What can 3D Touch do on the iPhone 6S and 6S Plus?

Pencil feature 9

Still, like the Surface Pen, the S Pen appears to trump the Apple Pencil on simple utility. It’s deeply integrated into the host device on more than just a physical level.

Samsung has fitted the S Pen out with a single button that brings up a radial menu wherever you are on the Note 5’s Android-based interface. This allows you to launch quick stylus-based tasks like memos and smart screen selections.

While it’s only a tiddler compared to the Apple Pencil, the S Pen is not without finesse. It sports what Samsung rather vaguely calls “true-to-life pressure sensitivity,” which basically means that when you press heavily you’ll get a thicker line just as you would with a fine pen or pencil. We doubt it’s as advanced as

Apple’s solution, but then it really doesn’t need to be.

This is a functional stylus meant for day to day usage across a number of productivity tasks - quite the opposite of the Apple Pencil, in other words.

Conclusion

It’s impossible to say if these rival stylus-driven platforms are superior to the Apple Pencil or not, but one thing is already abundantly clear. They benefit from being tightly integrated and indeed bundled with their host device.

Apple’s decision to make the Apple Pencil a stand-alone tool might be good for opening up your options, and for allowing the creation of a truly specialist tool with no cap on price or dimensions. But it will inevitably create a less cohesive pairing between it and the iPad Pro.

It will likely trump existing Bluetooth styluses through widespread app compatibility, and will top the more dependable capacitive styluses through its sensitivity and sophisticated range of inputs.

Will the Apple Pencil be something that will enhance your general iOS 9 navigation outside of a few specialist drawing apps? It’s highly unlikely, and that means it will be useful to far fewer people. But that's not to say it won't give its rivals something to think about.

Frederick Murre

September 28, 2015, 5:51 pm

It really isn't fair to include Wacom's standalone stylus here, as while it has ability within its own means for pressure sensitivity data via bluetooth, the iOS devices have no other hardware concession to it, and it must still emulate a finger, via an active voltage discharge.

The Apple pencil conversely has its own special hi-rez channel and frequency in the capacitance sense grid of the iPad Pro, in addition to transmitted pressure and orientation.

Surface 3/Pro3 products and Samsung use older at least initially more precise RF induction digitizers, with the Samsung and pre 3 Surfaces being Passive Induction, and the Ntrig digitizer in the 3/3Pro being Active Induction. Active induction is arguably more accurate, particularly at screen edges, at the cost of freighting around the stylus battery.

Dead Words

September 28, 2015, 9:04 pm

The fact that Apple hasn't mentioned hard numbers makes me feel they're pulling another Apple. They don't want people to know the numbers because they're not as high as the competition and therefore bad marketing. Not being as high as the competition isn't a bad thing, look at performance in Apple products, but it is what Apple does.

Dead Words

September 28, 2015, 9:05 pm

I'm looking forward to seeing how Microsoft improves the Surface Pen with the Surface Pro 4. The Pro 3 was the first time it was that useful and widespread and I feel it's going to be more polished with the Pro 4.

nmunky

September 29, 2015, 8:25 am

This review is all fine but it doesn't address the fundamental question about using any kind of stylus, which is how accurate it is. Pressure sensitivity and tilt functions are all well and good but if you're using a device which can't track closer than the nearest couple of millimetres there's no way any serious artist or designer can use it.
I've tried all sorts of styli for my iPad and all of them felt like drawing with boxing gloves on when compared to my trusty Wacom tablet.
How about an objective comparison of, for example, how closely a line on the screen appears to the one drawn by the tip of the stylus?

Dennis M Dewey

September 29, 2015, 4:09 pm

I think it's way too early to compare it to the competition. All you have to go on is vague specifications... and specs alone are not really that important. It's the combination of hardware and software that'll make or break a product. You should know this by now. It's all about the UX design and how responsive or sensitive it is. I'm even wondering if you really care all that much about styli in general and just wanted to create a linkbait / anti-Apple article.

The Wacom's Creative Stylus also had a terrible problem on iPad Air 2 with jagged lines. I returned it the next the day after agonizing over this issue. I could not believe that I just dropped almost $100 on a Wacom and was disappointed - usually Wacom devices have only brought me a sense of delight for the past 15 years. I'm going to have to check this out at the Apple Store and see for myself. If this stylus handles as well as I've seen, it won't need a button to help seal the deal. I've been using a Samsung Galaxy Note 10.2 2014 Edition for drawing nowadays but I'm excited to soon be able to draw using a real stylus in Procreate for iPad. Oh yeah - one of the drawbacks to the new Samsung Note is that it'll mess up your stylus/phone if you accidentally insert it backwards.

You also forget that many people use these things called "cases/covers" and I'm sure we're going to see a cover that has an Apple Pencil holder. I really don't think Apple is going to put a slot in the iPad Pro for an optional stylus.

Weak review and conclusions. You basically copied and pasted specs along with a few other tidbits that could've easily been obtained from 5 minutes of research.

harrydevlin

September 29, 2015, 7:22 pm

Wait a while. Apple only just recently invented pencils. Prior to this no one had a pencil.

Steve

October 6, 2015, 11:24 am

What I want to know is why people aren't talking about this Pencil-Gate?

Charging the Pencil by attaching it perpendicular to the edge of the tablet must be the daftest idea someone could come up with. It is just asking for trouble and I'm sure there are going to be lot of people complaining that they accidentally snapped the Pencil or damaged the lightning port by snagging the end of the Pencil due to the increased leverage.

Just imagine you're sitting there on the sofa with the tablet on your lap and Pencil sticking out to the side while charging. Your child or pet suddenly jumps on to the sofa beside you. Leverage.....and SNAP!

Surely it is the same thing as the S-Pen-Gate that people were complaining about poor design and also accidentally damaging it by storing it backwards?!?

TruB

November 19, 2015, 7:30 am

"What I want to know is why people aren't talking about this Pencil-Gate?

Charging the Pencil by attaching it perpendicular to the edge of the tablet must be the daftest idea someone could come up with. It is just asking for trouble and I'm sure there are going to be lot of people complaining that they accidentally snapped the Pencil or damaged the lightning port by snagging the end of the Pencil due to the increased leverage."

You NEED to plug it in to pair it once, BUT, you will get a charge cable along with the pencil and you don't need to recharge it through the iPad ever.. Conclusion, the concern is stupid..

TruB

November 19, 2015, 7:33 am

You mean like the new Iphone has double the ram but they didn't bother to tell anyone? yeah, users got screwed right there, typical Apple right?

Dead Words

November 19, 2015, 12:24 pm

Yes, typical Apple. Just because the RAM in the 6s duo got doubled doesn't mean it's high. It's still only 2GB of RAM and there's a reason Apple didn't make a huge deal about it. Did I once say that this habit of Apple's makes Apple products worse? Not at all. They still have great performance. But it's frustrating for someone who wants to know the specifics.

TruB

November 19, 2015, 2:27 pm

Agree to all you just said, but previously you made assumptions that it was bad just because, looking at performance it actually looks good. Personally, I think Apple is smart not to reveal specs, because only then people actually look at performance where they often win.

Dead Words

November 19, 2015, 8:59 pm

I didn't make any assumptions that the performance was worse, in fact I insinuated that performance in Apple products is generally very good, just lamented that I wished Apple would be more open as people like me want to know what we're getting. For me, at least, it's not because I want the best of the best, but because I want to get the best for me.

stealthmantiz

November 24, 2015, 5:03 am

It's hard to decide when Apple hasn't released it's pressure sensitivity. All I found was this video:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?...

stealthmantiz

November 24, 2015, 5:38 am

I wonder if the levels will show up in XCODE when working with it.

Ettercap

December 30, 2015, 2:53 pm

Why is S-Pen a winner?

It is housed inside of the device very conveniently if you accudentily leave it your phone gives you a warning that your leaving it behind, it does not require plugged charging it pulls energy from the device itself wirelessly, the Note 5's stylus is wacom and has 2,048 levels of pressure sensitivity.

A wirelessly charged stylus with 2,048 levels of pressure sensitivity and a button with multiple per app based functions how is that not a winner?

Yes it is lighter than an average pen or pencil and thinner but it's so extremely functional I can draw for hours with the Spen and it doesn't bother me it makes every touch and stroke super light and smooth.

I wish they would add the eraser function of the surface pen to the S-Pen but the S-Pen in my opinion already kills the competition it's 1000 times more functional than its competition.

comments powered by Disqus