Home / News / Laptop News / Surface Laptop vs MacBook Air: Which lightweight notebook is best?

Surface Laptop vs MacBook Air: Which lightweight notebook is best?

by

Surface Laptop vs MacBook Air

Surface Laptop vs MacBook Air: The MacBook Air has been the go-to lightweight laptop of choice for many, but Microsoft has a new challenger in the form of the Surface Book. Here's how the two compare.

Microsoft recently launched the new Windows 10 S alongside a shiny new device on which to show off the software: The Surface Laptop.

At around the £1000 mark, this isn't a cheap laptop by any means, but there's no denying the sleek design and effort that's seemingly gone into making this a premium product.

Of course, the price point and attention to aesthetics puts it in direct competition with Apple's dated MacBook Air. So, we thought we'd see how the two machines compare. Here's all you need to know:

Related: Surface Laptop vs Surface Book

Surface Laptop MacBook Air

Processors Dual-core 7th-gen Core i5 or i7 Dual-core 5th-gen Intel Core i5 or i7

Graphics Intel HD 620 or 640 Intel HD Graphics 6000
Memory 4-16GB 8GB
Storage 128-512GB SSD 128GB-512GB SSD
Weight 1.25kg 1.35kg
Thickness 14.5mm 17mm
Screen 13.5-inch 2256x1504-pixel touch screen 13.3-inch 1440x900-pixel display
Ports USB 3.0, 3.5mm audio, mini DisplayPort MagSafe 2, 2x USB 3, 3.5mm audio, Thunderbolt 2, SDXC card

Price £979-2149 £949-1099

Surface Laptop vs MacBook Air – Design

Microsoft might just be able to give Apple a run for its money with this latest device. There's no screws, joins, or hinges visible on the new laptop, and the company has also managed to pack the speakers below the keyboard, in order to hide the speaker grilles and project audio directly at you from behind the keys.

Of course, you also won't be seeing much in the way of screws, hinges, or speaker grilles on Apple's famously sleek laptop, unless you closely inspect the base of the thing. The important thing to note is that both these laptops look great and convey the attention to detail both companies have put into their respective designs.

One area where Microsoft has Apple beat, however, is portability. The Surface Laptop measures 9.9mm at the front and 14.47mm at the back, thanks to its tapered design. Meanwhile, the MacBook Air comes in at 17mm, though at its edges it reduces to about 3mm. It's also slightly heavier than the Surface Laptop. Microsoft's machine weighs 1.25kg, while the Air weighs 1.35kg. These are small differences, but there's no doubt Microsoft's machine is the more slight and portable offering.

Related: Surface Laptop vs Chromebook Pixel

macbook air

Microsoft has provided several colour options for its laptop: Platinum, Burgundy, Cobalt Blue, and Graphite Gold. Apple's machine comes in either Space Grey or Silver. Both feature backlit keys but Microsoft has taken the liberty of outfitting the Surface Laptop with Alcantara fabric on the area surrounding the keys.

There's no fuzzy keyboard tray on the MacBook Air, but whether that's an issue will come down to your personal preferences. We're yet to test out the keyboard mechanism on the Surface Laptop, but we found the keys on the Air to have a crisp, clean and light action, despite being slightly shallow.

On the sides of the Surface Laptop you'll find a USB port, Surface power connector, and a mini DisplayPort – no USB Type-C connection this time, unfortunately. Things are slightly more comprehensive on the Air. Apple's provided a MagSafe 2 power port, 2x USB 3 ports, a 3.5mm audio jack, Thunderbolt 2 port, and SDXC card slot.

Related: Windows 10 S laptops

surface laptop 15

Surface Laptop vs MacBook Air – Hardware and Performance

With the Surface Laptop, Microsoft has provided a 7th-generation Intel Core processor (i5 and i7 options available), along with either 4GB or 8GB of RAM, and a 128GB SSD, which can be expanded if you pay more. It's a decent set of specs, though not quite top-end stuff. It should provide speedy performance, especially if you opt for the 8GB RAM version with any of the processor upgrades.

All the various configurations can be slightly confusing, so here's a table of all the different setups available and how much they cost:

Microsoft Surface Laptop:

Option 1

Option 2

Option 3

Option 4

Processor Intel Core i5

Intel Core i5

Intel Core i7

Intel Core i7

Storage 128GB SSD

256GB SSD

256GB SSD

512GB SSD

RAM 4GB 8GB 8GB 16GB
Graphics

Intel HD Graphics 620

Intel HD Graphics 620

Intel Iris Plus Graphics 640

Intel Iris Plus Graphics 640

Colour Platinum Burgundy, Platinum, Cobalt Blue, Graphite Gold

Platinum Platinum
Price

£979 / $999

£1,249 / $1,299

£1,549 / $1,599

£2,149 / $2,199

So, how does the MacBook Air stack up? Well, you'll also find a dual-core Intel Core i5 or i7 depending on whether you want to upgrade. However the processors used in this laptop are 5th generation Intel chips, as opposed to the much newer 7th generation processors used in the Surface Laptop. This means they're both less powerful and less efficient, and this becomes very obvious when you push the MacBook Air hard: the fans fire up to a cacophony and it gets very hot.

The Air comes equipped with 8GB of RAM as standard (topping the standard 4GB on the Surface Laptop) and flash storage of either 128GB, 256GB, or 512GB depending on how much you want to pay. What with 8GB of RAM and flash storage, you should be getting a nice, fluid user experience on the MacBook Air, especially since the hardware was designed with MacOS in mind.

Related: 13-inch MacBook Pro (2016) review

Surface Laptop

Aside from newer processors, The Surface Laptop also has an edge on the MacBook with its stylus support. You'll be able to use Microsoft's Surface Pen to doodle on your display and make notes if you feel inclined. And that display isn't too bad either. Microsoft has provided a 13.5-inch, 3.4 million-pixel LCD touchscreen with a 3:2 aspect ratio and 2256 x 1504 resolution. That resolution on a 13-inch display should make for a sharp image, and we're expecting it to be vibrant, too.

Apple, for its part, has kitted out the MacBook Air with a 13.3-inch LED-backlit screen featuring a 1440 x 900 resolution. That's a significantly lower resolution than the Surface Laptop, and in this day and age is well below par, both in terms of resolution and colour coverage. It's the weakest part of the MacBook Air and puts it well behind not just the Surface Laptop, but also most other premium Windows 10 machines.

Related: Best laptops

macbook air

On the software side, you'll find Microsoft's new Windows 10 S running the show on the Surface Laptop. What is it? You can read our full guide to the new operating system here, but essentially, it's Microsoft's attempt to provide a stripped-down version of the WIndows 10 OS.

With a simplified, redesigned home screen, the new version of Windows only allows users to install applications from the Windows Store. It's a more locked down version of the full OS that's designed to give teachers and administrators more control over the system.

Naturally, the MacBook Air runs Apple's own macOS Sierra. The latest version of the operating system, macOS Sierra, is a great iteration of the software, with a load of new features such as iCloud Desktop synchronisation, Siri integration, Apple Pay support built into Safari, and a load of other neat touches that make the OS a pleasure to use.

Related: WWDC 2017

MacBook Air

Surface Laptop vs MacBook Air – Price and release date

You can pre-order the Surface Laptop right now, with the device set to ship and hit stores on June 15. The basic configuration is priced at £979 in the UK and $999 in the US, while more expensive models will run you up to £2149 in the UK and $2199 in the states.

Pre-order: Surface Laptop from £979

Apple's machine is ever so slightly more affordable. The MacBook Air starts at £949 in the UK and $999 in the US, but could run you as much as £1409 ($1549) if you want the top-spec version. Apple seems to have abandoned the Air entirely, so don't expect a new version to arrive any time soon.

Surface Laptop or MacBook Pro, which is best? Let us know your thoughts in the comments.

comments powered by Disqus