Japan Says Hybrid Cars Too Quiet

Author Hugo Jobling
Published 3rd Jul 2009
Japan Says Hybrid Cars Too Quiet
Bookmark and Share discuss this article  28 comments    Email  Email trustedreviews newslettersTrustedReviews Newsletters

Hybrid cars might arguably be better for the environment, but according to the Japanese Transport Ministry, they could be dangerous to some pedestrians, as a result of their near-silence at low speeds. As a result, hybrid vehicles might be required to come equipped with a noise-making device.


The concern is that when operating on battery power it is difficult to hear a hybrid vehicle coming, which could make it a risk for the visually impaired. According to the Transport Ministry is "received opinions from automobile users and vision-impaired people that they feel hybrid vehicles are dangerous."

In response to those concerns, the Transport Ministry gathered a panel of "scholars, vision-impaired groups, consumers, police and the automobile industry to discuss the issue." Their conclusion? "To consider introducing a sound-making function" in hybrid vehicles. Profound!

Far be it for me to point out that even though the engine noise of hybrid vehicles is - generally - greatly lessened they do still produce tyre noise when moving and, perhaps more notably, are generally moving within other traffic. One quiet car amount hundreds of loud ones hardly poses a threat. Not to say that there are probably some occasions where a silent vehicle could be an issue; I just can't think of any.

Whether export-vehicles would be affected should regulations require hybrid vehicle manufacturers in Japan to add sound-emitters to their vehicles is, unsurprisingly, unclear. It's an interesting possibility to bear in mind, though - I'll take a quacking Prius, please.

Link:
AFP.

discuss this article  28 comments
Email this article to a friend Email
Bookmark and Share
 

Newsletters

Register to receive the latest Reviews and News Headlines directly to your Inbox every day, and enter our regular competitions. More Info.

Your Name


Email Address


Latest 4 of 28 Comments

Have your say: Leave a comment below about this article.

comment Castalan said on 4th July 2009

My point is that if drivers cant rely on the sheer volume of their cars approach into making pedestrians wary - maybe they will slow down to reasonable speeds in urban areas. the ... more

comment stranded said on 5th July 2009

This is ridiculous. Normal cars are dangerous. Maybe make all cars quiet (except real sport cars)?

comment Tony Walker said on 5th July 2009

@Castalan

You've been driving for 30 years coz you haven't reached your destination yet.

Speeds are fine where they are. Pedestrians need ed... more

comment AnRuaRI said on 6th July 2009

This is a very simple issue: The problem only exists at low speed for 2 reasons:
1) Hybrids only operate on electric only at low speed.
2) petrol and diesel cars emit... more

See all 28 comments on this article.

add comment Add your comment

You must be logged in to comment. Login or register here.