Philips DVDR5520H DVD/HDD Recorder - Philips DVDR5520H

By Danny Phillips

Reviewed:

Summary

Our Score:

8

The features don't end there. The deck is DivX Ultra certified, which means it plays all versions of the video compression codec along with advanced features like subtitles and alternate audio tracks. MP3, WMA and JPEG are also supported, plus the unit is compatible with Dolby Digital and DTS soundtracks (available in bitstream form from the coaxial digital output). And while we're discussing format support, it happily spins any recordable DVD you throw at it (except DVD-RAM) plus CD-R, CD-RW and Video CDs.

Having recently waded through the wealth of easy-to-use editing functions on the latest Panasonic recorders, we found Philips' editing options very limited and not exactly intuitive. The unit is hamstrung by its linear way of working - you can't, for instance, take clips from any recording and piece them together in a new sequence. You can remove chapters by setting markers as the video plays and then ‘hide' them so it skips that section when played back, but the results aren't always accurate.

However, it makes up for this with a brilliant feature called Commercial Block, which will be a godsend to those of you who hate adverts (i.e. everyone). With Smart chaptering activated, the unit automatically inserts chapter points at the beginning and end of every ad break, allowing you to jump past them by pressing the chapter skip key. In action it works magnificently, both with recordings from an external set-top box or the built-in tuner, placing markers in exactly the right place. It even works with programmes on Five, where the logo that flashes up between each advert could have been a problem. On the downside, it has to process the video in standby before the feature is available (a 30-minute recording takes one hour to process) but it's definitely worth the wait.

In operation, the DVDR5520H is a touch hesitant and some key features (such as the recording mode and HDMI resolution settings) are buried in submenus rather than being given their own buttons on the remote. But it would have been a lot worse had the remote not been such a work of genius - it's fitted with a control wheel that makes it easy to search through the Time Shift Buffer and setup menus, plus the other buttons are ideally placed.

For recordings, you can choose from seven recording quality settings - the best is HQ, which is good for 23 hours recording time on the hard-disk, and offers deep, rich colours and a decent amount of detail, demonstrated by the garish colour schemes of daytime TV studios and intricate patterns of the presenters' tasteless attire. Straight lines are slightly jagged and block noise is visible but the overall results are still impressive.

Wakefield Electronics

February 12, 2009, 12:56 pm

1. Software "unstable". Mostly fixed by latest update but still poor.


2. Must be manually switched off at night to get programme guide updates.


3. Very slow to function sometimes causing you to press the remote a second time thinking it didn't pick up the first signal with annoying consequences.


4. Hard drive a little too noisey.


5. No RF modualator so you cannot watch through the aerial cable, only HDMI or AV (SCART).





On the plus side the HDMI picture is okay.





Overall, still someway behind HUMAX.

Lloyd

April 8, 2009, 3:31 am

Very unpredictable.


Newest firmware 3.07 still very poor.


Annoyingly slow through the menus.


Guideplus system hit and miss.


Would appear to have been rushed to the market.


For me the best feature is being able to play AVI files directly from a USB stick, but does not out way the other MAJOR flaws with this unit.

Les Maxwell

July 7, 2009, 2:19 am

Painfully slow starting so allow time before programme you want to record


Can't view/record Satellite (Sky) channels even though connected through sat box (maybe a fault?)


Sometimes freezes when in "Starting" mode


Complicated and fiddly remote control which doesn't appear to do what it says on the box


Has started time Shift recording but then failed and restarted causing 2/3 minute gap in recording











Nevertheless pretty decent for the price I paid

sheila m smith

April 1, 2010, 9:54 pm

very slow startup and does freeze a lot it also deletes recordings when there is still plenty of room left on hard drive very annoying i think this is a beta machine

comments powered by Disqus