Comments on Pentax Optio P80

Name withheld

MrGodfrey

1:57 PM on 26 October, 2009

This comment is hidden because you have chosen to ignore MrGodfrey. Show DetailsHide Details

I agree Pentax can do so much better than this. I disagree that their compacts have only got worse over the last 5 years or so. The last of the "S" range retained excellent build and image quality. But the newer range, the P, M and E series; have been horribly uninspired. They are not bad as such; the problem is more that they do not stand out at all. Either very little time and effort were put into the design, or they were specifically designed to be as boring as possible, so that no-one would tell it was a Pentax without reading the name. The waterproof W series at least have a unique(ish) selling point, however the decision to make these look and feel like cheap plastic toys was a terrible one.





However Pentax are not alone in disappointing with their compacts; I think Olympus have lost sight of what made their compacts different since the days of the wonderful Mju Mini. Nikon's compact range is also fairly tedious, other than the P-series, and gives no indication of the quality evident in their dSLRs. Canon have at least maintained a consistent approach to their designs (though I am not a great fan for other reasons).





It seems to me that optics/camera companies are just surrendering the compact market to electronics companies. Panasonic compacts are now, for many, the standard by which others are judged. In addition to excellent build quality, they put a lot of thought into the control system and the automated metering, focusing etc, to produce cameras that the average consumer can use with minimal effort and produce images that are instantly suitable for printing. In other words, they actually spent time and money thinking about what features could be improved and what consumers wanted. Meanwhile Nikon, Pentax etc simply churned out me-too clone cameras, albeit with a few more pixels each time. Similarly, Samsung may have some way to go in terms of implementation, but in terms of design they are at least trying new ideas, and new approaches to existing ones. If Apple decided to wade in as well, then all of those traditional optics companies may as well pack up and go home.





The thing is, right now no compacts (other than expensive niche ones) really stand out in terms of the quality of images they can potentially produce. Therefore they have to compete with unique designs and/or unique feature sets, which can be advertised effectively. Just having slightly more pixels will not do anymore, and HD video may be appealing but not when it's simply crammed in as an afterthought, like in the P80 here. I'm sure Pentax et al realise this; I just hope they get their act together and either step their game up, or give up.





OK, that's my essay for the day ;)