Home / Computing / Printer / Dell 2150cdn / Performance and Verdict

Dell 2150cdn - Performance and Verdict

By Simon Williams

Reviewed:

Summary

Our Score:

8

Dell rates this printer at 23ppm in black and colour. We rate it at a maximum of 17.7ppm, printing a 20-page black text document. That’s a good bit short of the claimed speed and without a draft mode and with only a few seconds spent processing before paper starts to feed, it’s hard to see where Dell’s figures come from.

On shorter, 5-page documents, the speeds we recorded were 11.5ppm for black and 12ppm for colour, only around half the speed on the spec sheet. Since the average length of an office document is still four pages, these are the speeds you're more likely to see.

Compare them with those from the Brother HL-4140CN at around the same price, though not a duplex machine. It's rated at 22ppm but, on the same five-page documents, gave speeds of 14.3ppm and 9.7ppm, respectively. Dell has a definite edge with the colour print speed, but lags significantly when printing in black.

Print quality, from the machine’s 600dpi engine, is more than good enough for anything you’re likely to want in an office. Black text is very sharp and clean, with well-formed characters showing no misplaced toner and being especially dense and black in headings and other emboldened text.

Colour graphics are also dense and bright, ideal for clear, visually attractive graphs and charts and with no signs of misalignment when printing black text over colour backgrounds.

Even a photo print, not most colour lasers’ favourite subject matter, came through with less of the seaside postcard effect that a limited colour range can often produce. Here the image was smooth, with no sign of banding and good levels of detail. The dot pitch is just about visible, but by no means obtrusive.

Toner cartridges are available in 1,200 and 3,000 page versions for black and 1,200 and 2,500-page versions for each of the colours. The high-yield black cartridge is also available in a twin pack, giving further economy over the price of the single one.

Using the cheapest consumables available from the Dell site gives a cost per ISO page of 3.0p for black and 13.8p for colour, including 0.7p for paper. Again, using the Brother HL-4140CN for comparison, the running costs are very similar for both machines and comparing more widely, this Dell is bang in the middle of the field of its main competitors.

Verdict

Dell’s 2150cdn is a good, workgroup colour printer, producing excellent prints at reasonable cost, though not always as quickly as some of its rivals. It would be good to have niceties such as a front panel USB port and a multipurpose tray that could handle more than a single sheet at a time. Even so, it represents good value for money and is a sturdy, deliberate workhorse.

jake120

January 18, 2011, 11:44 pm

This is not about the review as much as it is about the word “workgroup” used by the printer / copier industry. This unit and others like it in the real world would be ok in an office of 1 to 3 people. To me a workgroup is 5 people. If you put this unit and other like it in a workgroup of 5 people they would be pulling their hair out by the end of the month if not sooner. Because they would be spending more time replenishing the trays and replacing the toner then they should. I wish the industry would quick using these types of words to mislead business / people and misrepresent their products.





I am in the business of servicing and selling laser products. I have seen quite a few office using products that are either to small or too large for the environment they are in, because they take the word of the manufacture and or dealer using such words as “workgroup”. They should be talking a closer look at the paper and the toner capacity the unit has in comparison to what the end users might need. Then look at the speed that would be required in the office.





Thanks for all your reviews.

comments powered by Disqus