TrustedReviews
  • Home
    • All Reviews
    • All News
    • All Videos
    • All Round-Ups
    • All Features
  • TVs & Entertainment
    • Blu-ray Players
    • Gadgets
    • Games
    • Games Accessories
    • Headphones
    • Portable Audio
    • Projectors
    • Surround Sound Systems
    • TV Recorders & Set Top Boxes
    • TVs
  • Cameras
    • Camcorders
    • Camera Accessories
    • Camera Lenses
    • Digital Cameras
  • Laptops & Computing
    • Desktop PCs
    • Laptops
    • Monitors
    • PC Components
    • Peripherals
    • Printers
    • Software
    • Tablets
    • Broadband Deals
  • Mobile & GPS
    • GPS & Sat Nav
    • Mobile Apps
    • Mobile Phone Accessories
    • Mobile Phones
    • Mobile Deals
  • Video Reviews
Home » Cameras » Camcorder » Canon Legria HF S10 » Video

Canon Legria HF S10 video review

  • More Photos
  • Video

We're still only in March and 2009 is already turning out to be a bumper year for camcorders - credit crunch be damned. Canon knew it had to pull out all the stops with the successor to last year's HF10 and HF11, and in terms of features and quality it has. We still prefer Panasonic's lens ring to Canon's wheel when focusing, and the HDC-HS300's use of a standard accessory shoe leaves your peripheral options open. But in other respects the Legria HF S10 provides an even more mature set of controls. Our only concern, yet again, is the price. Camcorder costs have increased by around 20 per cent due to the weakness of the pound. But even taking that into consideration, the S10 is hugely expensive. So although it's another great camcorder, in the current economic climate its greatness is likely to reach fewer purchasers than it should. Read full review

Overall

9/10

User Rating

1/10

  • Read 1 user reviews
  • Write your own review

By James Morris
Reviewed 21 March 2009
Updated 26 May 2011

Price as reviewed

£1,299.00

  • Review
    • 1: Canon Legria HF S10
    • 2: Canon Legria HF S10
    • 3: Canon Legria HF S10
  • Video Review
  • User Reviews
  • Comments
  • Specs
  • 8 Photos
  • Reviewed by James Morris
  • 21 March 2009
Read the full Canon Legria HF S10 review
Tweet

More Camcorder Videos

  • Sony HDR-TD20VESony HDR-TD20VE
  • Toshiba Camileo X400Toshiba Camileo X400
  • JVC HD Everio GZ-E205JVC HD Everio GZ-E205
  • Panasonic HX-WA2Panasonic HX-WA2

compare prices

Awards

  • Recommended by TR

Canon Legria HF S10 details

Value
7/10
Image Quality
10/10
Features
9/10
Overall
9/10

Price as reviewed

£1,299.00

Manufacturer

Canon

Camcorder round-ups

  1. TrustedReviews 2011 Awards

    Camcorder Of The Year 2011

    We reveal the Best Camcorder of 2011.

  2. Best Camcorder

    Top Ten Best Camcorders

    Our pick of the ten best camcorders currently on the market, from 3D-touting dual-lens behemoths to enthusiast-friendly models and rugged, pocket camcorders for those looking to capture life on the edge.

More Camcorder Round-ups

TrustedReviews newsletter

Get TrustedReviews' award-winning reviews, opinions and advice delivered to your inbox for free!


Three of the best High end Camcorders

  1. Panasonic HDC-TM900

    Our rating:
    10/10
    User rating:
    9/10

    Can Panasonic maintain its position as our favourite enthusiast camcorder manufacturer?

  2. Canon LEGRIA HF G10

    Our rating:
    9/10

    The Canon LEGRIA HF G10 shows the company still has plenty to offer the serious videomaker.

  3. Panasonic HDC-Z10000

    Panasonic HDC-Z10000

    Our rating:
    9/10

    The Panasonic HDC-Z10000 provides professional-grade 3D shooting at a fraction of the cost of professional-grade camcorders.

 

User reviews & comments

Comments

To leave a comment log in or sign up
 

Please wait while we process your request
 

Please wait while we retrieve the user's information

Bio

Your bio is currently empty. Now is a great time to fill in your profile.

This profile is private.

This profile is only shared with friends.

This profile is under review.

We were unable to request friendship with this user.

We were unable to request friendship with this user. Are you logged in?

Your friendship request has been sent to this user.

We were unable to terminate friendship with this user.

We were unable to terminate friendship with this user. Are you logged in?

You are no longer friends with this user.

We were unable to ignore this user.

We were unable to ignore this user. Are you logged in?

This user is now ignored.

We were unable to stop ignoring this user.

We were unable to stop ignoring this user. Are you logged in?

This user is no longer ignored.

We encountered a problem recommending this user.

pluck_user_recommend_permission

You have recommended this user.

pluck_user_mp-abuse_too_long_err

Send Cancel

Please wait while we perform your request.

Leave a comment

53 comments

Sort:

Name withheld

Isaac Sarayiah

12:10 AM on 21 March, 2009

This comment is hidden because you have chosen to ignore Isaac Sarayiah. Show DetailsHide Details

Sounds like its the Panasonic for me then.

Abuse reported Report abuse
0
Score:
0 replies1 reply 0 replies1 reply Please wait while we perform your request.

Name withheld

ChrisPhilpot

10:05 AM on 21 March, 2009

This comment is hidden because you have chosen to ignore ChrisPhilpot. Show DetailsHide Details

I have to agree - the lack of a lens ring is the killer blow for me, which is a shame as it's the more attractive model in many other respects.





So, as someone considering spending £1000ish on a semi-pro camera over the coming months, what would the users and staff of TrustedReviews recommend?

Abuse reported Report abuse
0
Score:
0 replies1 reply 0 replies1 reply Please wait while we perform your request.

Name withheld

James Morris

10:28 AM on 21 March, 2009

This comment is hidden because you have chosen to ignore James Morris. Show DetailsHide Details

Well, the S10 probably is the best consumer camcorder I've ever tested, but the £300 price difference with the HS300 is pretty significant, and it's not much smaller despite using Flash memory rather than a hard disk for storage.

Abuse reported Report abuse
0
Score:
0 replies1 reply 0 replies1 reply Please wait while we perform your request.

Name withheld

James Morris

11:26 AM on 21 March, 2009

This comment is hidden because you have chosen to ignore James Morris. Show DetailsHide Details

The little wheel is still pretty good - just not quite as intuitive as a full lens ring.

Abuse reported Report abuse
0
Score:
0 replies1 reply 0 replies1 reply Please wait while we perform your request.

Name withheld

Ivo1

12:58 PM on 21 March, 2009

This comment is hidden because you have chosen to ignore Ivo1. Show DetailsHide Details

which camcorder has the best video quality HF s10 or Pansasonic hdc-hs300


what is the best buy

Abuse reported Report abuse
0
Score:
0 replies1 reply 0 replies1 reply Please wait while we perform your request.

Name withheld

Ripsnorter

2:36 PM on 21 March, 2009

This comment is hidden because you have chosen to ignore Ripsnorter. Show DetailsHide Details

Definitely a review I've been waiting for. Now if only the decision as to whether the Canon or Panasonic were easy! German magazine Bild Audio Video Foto put them up against each other in the March edition.





The Panasonic +'s with its colour viewfinder, 5.1 sound, focus ring, touchscreen and microphone and headphone connections. It -'s with its battery lasting only 2 hours. The final score is 2.07 (with 1.00 being the best possible).





The Canon +'s with its video light, rotary ring settings adjustment, microphone and headphone connections and video snapshot function. It gets minus points for not having a viewfinder and the battery being rechargable only in the camera. Its final score is 2.31 points.





Without my wishing to appear pro or contra either model, the Panasonic beat out the Canon in all disciplines with the exception of the cost of replacement batteries. Here, as in the UK, there is also a significant price difference between the two, with the magazine quoting E899 for the Panasonic and E1499 for the Canon. I have yet to see the Canon in the shops but have seen the Panasonic, but at E999.00

Abuse reported Report abuse
0
Score:
0 replies1 reply 0 replies1 reply Please wait while we perform your request.

Name withheld

James Morris

4:52 PM on 21 March, 2009

This comment is hidden because you have chosen to ignore James Morris. Show DetailsHide Details

I've tested the two side-by-side now in some conditions, and the S10 does have superior image quality, although this is most noticeable in low light. The 1.7x digital telephoto is surprisingly useful, too, as this gives you a 17x zoom over the normal fully wide image, with no perceptible loss of resolution in good lighting. If they were the same price, I'd probably lean towards the S10. But the extra image quality and few extra menu features are not worth the current price difference. The HF S100, though, might be worth considering, as you can pick up two 16GB SDHC cards for about £50 now.

Abuse reported Report abuse
0
Score:
0 replies1 reply 0 replies1 reply Please wait while we perform your request.

Name withheld

SergeiMutovkin

7:29 PM on 21 March, 2009

This comment is hidden because you have chosen to ignore SergeiMutovkin. Show DetailsHide Details

Everybody mentions Panasonic. But what about Sony and their XR500V and XR520V models? No early 2009 camcorder decision would be complete without Sony consideration. I'm really interested how image stabilization compares in these cameras as it seems that even if camcorder has better image quality it gets ruined by constant motions. From what I've seen from Japanese website samples Canon gives over-saturated image and has much worse image stabilization than Sony. However 24Mbps vs 16Mbps helps Canon to capture more details (and its own sensor noise).

Abuse reported Report abuse
0
Score:
0 replies1 reply 0 replies1 reply Please wait while we perform your request.

Name withheld

Ivo1

9:25 PM on 21 March, 2009

This comment is hidden because you have chosen to ignore Ivo1. Show DetailsHide Details

maybe the Panasonic Lumix GH1 a total solution

Abuse reported Report abuse
0
Score:
0 replies1 reply 0 replies1 reply Please wait while we perform your request.

Name withheld

James Morris

10:06 PM on 21 March, 2009

This comment is hidden because you have chosen to ignore James Morris. Show DetailsHide Details

@Sergei Mutovkin I will gladly include Sony's new models in the mix when Sony actually bothers to send them for review. But, from previous experience, we'd have to go out and buy them first. We keep trying, though, so watch this space.

Abuse reported Report abuse
0
Score:
0 replies1 reply 0 replies1 reply Please wait while we perform your request.
Powered by Pluck - Integrated Social Media Platform, Community Software and Custom Content Solutions for Digital Leaders
Next
 

What Do You Think?

To leave a comment, you need to sign up.

Sign up Sign in

Please wait while we file your abuse report.

Report Abuse

We're sorry. We were unable to report abuse at this time.

We limit the number of reactions an individual user can submit over a given period for quality reasons. You have currently reached that limit. Please try resubmitting your abuse report again later.

Comment is too long. Enter 500 characters or less.

Send Cancel

Please wait while we send the email.

Email This

You may send this to 5 e-mail addresses. Please separate each address with a space.

We're sorry, but the item you are sending has been removed from the site.

We're sorry. We were unable to send the email at this time.

Please specify a recipient.

You can only send messages to 5 addresses at a time.

The address "" is not valid.

Please specify a subject.

Send Cancel
Email Delicious Digg Facebook LinkedIn Messenger Connect MySpace
Copy to Clipboard Reddit Slashdot StumbleUpon Tumblr Twitter Yahoo! Buzz
Copy to clipboard

Score
 vote upvotes up
 vote downvotes down

User reviews

Average user rating

1/10

Read more reviews >

1/10

0 out of 0 people found this review helpful

cannon legria hf s 10=junk

3rd March 2012, By karl h

The worst I ever had,never gona buy an other cannon.What ever is good about it is canceled by the fact that when you zoom in at anything at any distance the picture is blur as it can be.Absolute JUNK! I expect nothing less of any camera in any price bracket to be able to focus and produce a clear picture,and perhapse than talk about any other mumbo-jumbo!HMMMM...let me see I got the JUNK for two years now,spent at least a week (168 hours) trying to record on memory card,(presed every button million times)and other than a blue line aroud,nothing yet.Thanks god I still got my SONY DCR TRV 520 E

Report abuse

To add your own review log in or sign up

Explore TrustedReviews

Site Sections

  • Blu-ray Players
  • Camcorders
  • Camera Accessories
  • Camera Lenses
  • Desktop PCs
  • Digital Cameras
  • Gadgets
  • Games
  • Games Accessories
  • GPS & Sat Nav
  • Headphones
  • Laptops
  • Mobile Apps
  • Mobile Phone Accessories
  • Mobile Phones
  • Monitors
  • PC Components
  • Peripherals
  • Portable Audio
  • Printers
  • Projectors
  • Software
  • Surround Sound Systems
  • Tablets
  • TV Recorders & Set Top Boxes
  • TVs

Round-ups

  • Best Cheap Mobile Phones
  • Best Phone
  • Best PC
  • Best Laptop
  • Best Printers
  • Best Digital Cameras
  • Best Waterproof Cameras
  • Best Headphones 2012
  • Best HTC Phones
  • Best MP3 Player
  • Best Ultrabook
  • Best Speakers
  • New iPad / iPad 3: Everything You Need To Know
  • Apple iPad 3 / iPad HD Launch Event
  • Best Surround Sound Systems

Tools and Social

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • RSS feeds
  • Sitemap

More Information

  • About us
  • Contact us
  • Advertising info
  • © IPC Media 2003-2012, All rights reserved
  • Site user terms
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Information
  • Contact Us